Harvard Has Real Magna Carta Text

Hidden In Plain Sight: £7 'Copy' of Magna Carta at Harvard Unveiled as £10 Million Original

A document, long dismissed as a mere inexpensive imitation of Magna Carta and acquired by Harvard Law School for a pittance, has now electrified the academic world. British scholars assert this unassuming parchment is, in fact, an authentic and immensely valuable original from the year 1300. This groundbreaking revelation elevates the manuscript from a dusty library note to potentially among the globe's most prized historical items. The law school obtained the item in 1946 for the modest sum of $27.50, roughly equivalent to seven British pounds during that period. For decades, its true nature remained obscured within the institution's archives.

Two distinguished professors of medieval history have now definitively established its status as an extraordinarily scarce, and a priorly misplaced, genuine Magna Carta. This specific charter dates to King Edward I's period of rule, an era of crucial legal development in England. The potential monetary worth of this find could run into many millions of pounds. This discovery underscores the often-surprising historical treasures that can lie dormant in collections, awaiting expert re-examination. The journey of this document, from its creation in medieval England to its rediscovery in a modern American university, is a captivating tale.

An Unlikely Discovery in Digital Archives

King's College London's Professor David Carpenter, a respected figure in medieval history, initiated the reappraisal. His curiosity sparked while perusing digitised images on Harvard Law School's website for a book project. He described the find as "a truly remarkable find". Professor Carpenter emphasised that the Harvard Magna Carta merits acknowledgment not as some discoloured and deteriorated replica, but as a genuine example from world history's most pivotal constitutional texts. He further elaborated that it serves as a cornerstone for liberties, both past and future.

The academic expressed profound astonishment, not only at uncovering this genuine version but also at the fact that its true significance had eluded recognition for so many years. This lack of awareness led to its sale for what he termed "peanuts". Records from the Harvard Law School Library for 1946 identify the item using the catalogue reference HLS MS 172. At that juncture, an auctioneer's listing described it merely as a 'reproduction created in 1327... showing some wear and moisture marks'. In 2025 monetary values, the initial $27.50 acquisition cost from 1946 would be around $450, or £339.

The Enduring Significance of Magna Carta

King John initially promulgated Magna Carta in England at Runnymede in June 1215; it stands as a monumental charter of rights. It emerged from a political crisis, forced upon the unpopular monarch by rebellious barons. The charter's primary aim was to make peace, guaranteeing protections for church rights, shielding barons from unlawful imprisonment, ensuring access to swift justice, and placing limitations on feudal payments to the Crown. Crucially, it established the principle that the king and his government were not above the law.

This document is widely viewed as a critical advancement in the long development of protections for individuals against despotic governance. Its principles have profoundly shaped how nations worldwide structured their fundamental laws, including the United States Constitution and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The original 1215 charter was subsequently reissued by successive monarchs, with modifications, in years like 1216, 1217, 1225, and 1297, leading up to the 1300 version now identified at Harvard. These reissues, often termed "confirmations," aimed to reaffirm the charter's principles and secure political support or funds.

Image Credit - BBC

The 1300 Edition: A Rarity Confirmed

The Magna Carta edition from 1300 holds particular historical importance. This confirmation came from King Edward I, and scribes produced numerous copies for distribution throughout England. Professor Carpenter states that "well over 30" such copies might have been created. Before the Harvard discovery, only six other originals of the 1300 Magna Carta were known to survive, all located in England. The addition of the Harvard manuscript makes it the seventh known original from this specific issue.

Professor Nicholas Vincent from the University of East Anglia, an expert in medieval history, collaborated with Professor Carpenter in authenticating the Harvard document. Professor Vincent described Magna Carta as a "totem of liberty," central to a collective identity of freedom. He noted that the 1300 version was the last full official reissue by the English monarchy, underscoring its significance. The meticulous textual consistency among the 1300 exemplars suggests a deliberate effort to ensure uniformity, highlighting the charter's established status by that time.

Tracing the Parchment's Path: From Appleby to Harvard

How HLS MS 172 reached the Harvard Law School archives is a fascinating narrative spanning centuries and continents. Professors Carpenter and Vincent believe its beginnings are thought to be in Appleby, an English town, then in Westmorland, now part of Cumbria. A Magna Carta confirmation was issued to Appleby in 1300, and historical records last noted its presence there in 1762 before it vanished from sight. The academics propose that the Harvard manuscript is likely this lost Appleby charter.

The presumed path involves the Lowther family, significant landowners in the Appleby region. It is thought they gave the historical item to Thomas Clarkson, a prominent 1780s abolitionist campaigner. Subsequently, Thomas Clarkson's estate, and the charter with it, transitioned through several heirs, ultimately coming into the possession of the Maynard family. AVM Forster Maynard, towards 1945's conclusion, a decorated Royal Air Force officer and World War I flying ace, offered it for sale through a Sotheby's auction. A London bookselling firm, Sweet & Maxwell, acquired it for £42 before Harvard purchased it months later for the much lower sum of $27.50.

The Science of Authentication

Confirming the authenticity of a centuries-old document like HLS MS 172 requires rigorous scholarly investigation and modern scientific techniques. Because significant portions of the manuscript exhibit severe fading, the professors initially worked from high-quality digital images. Librarians at Harvard Law School procured these images through the application of ultraviolet illumination and spectral analysis techniques, technologies that can reveal details invisible to the naked eye. This non-invasive approach is crucial for examining fragile historical artefacts.

With great care, Professor Carpenter and Professor Vincent assessed the physical attributes and written content of the Harvard artifact against the six other recognized 1300 exemplars. They noted that its dimensions, approximately 489mm by 473mm (around 19 by 19 inches), matched these examples. The style of handwriting, particularly the large capital 'E' in 'Edwardus' (referring to King Edward I) and the elongated letters in the first line, also corresponded. Most tellingly, the text stated the document was issued in "the 28th year of Edward's reign," dating it precisely to 1300.

Image Credit - BBC

Verifying the Textual Integrity

A crucial element of the authentication involved a detailed collation of the text. Magna Carta's phrasing changed through its various reissues. Therefore, for the Harvard document to be a genuine 1300 original, its terminology and exact sequence had to be an identical match to what appeared in the six other authenticated versions from that specific year. Professor Carpenter explained that the clerks responsible for producing the 1300 charters received strict instructions to adhere to a newly prepared text, ensuring remarkable uniformity.

This critical textual examination the Harvard manuscript completed 'with flying colours,' its content perfectly aligning with the other 1300 versions. This uniformity, Professor Carpenter highlighted, offers fresh evidence of Magna Carta's established status in the eyes of contemporaries; the text had to be exact. This meticulous replication provides a strong basis for its authentication as an official royal issuance, not merely a contemporaneous copy or later transcription.

The Value of a Lost Original

The monetary value of such a rare historical document is immense. While Professor Vincent hesitated to name an exact figure, he pointed to a relevant precedent: a Magna Carta from 1297 achieved $21.3 million (around £10.5 million during that period) when it went to auction in New York during 2007. This sale of what was then thought to be the only original Magna Carta in the United States, acquired by philanthropist David Rubenstein, indicates the significant sums such artefacts command. The Harvard 1300 original is now the second such genuine Magna Carta residing in the US.

Beyond its financial worth, the true value of the Harvard Magna Carta lies in its historical and cultural significance. Professor Carpenter described HLS MS 172 as "a remarkable testament to a fundamental stage in England's political development" and among the globe's most precious written records. Its rediscovery adds another crucial piece to the puzzle of how this foundational text was disseminated and preserved, offering new avenues for research and public engagement.

Surviving Magna Cartas: A Scarce Legacy

Just a few genuine Magna Carta official copies remain from the different issuances spanning 1215 to 1300. Of the initial 1215 charter, just four originals are known to exist. Two reside in the British Library (one of which suffered fire damage in 1731), one is at Lincoln Cathedral, and another at Salisbury Cathedral. These were handwritten by different scribes, likely in haste, to meet the demand for distribution across the kingdom.

Subsequent reissues also have limited surviving copies. The confirmation of the Harvard manuscript as a seventh original from the 1300 issue is a significant addition to this select group. Other original Magna Cartas are kept in various locations. For instance, besides the Harvard document, a 1297 official copy rests within the United States National Archives. Australia's Parliament House in Canberra safeguards another 1297 version. Each surviving original is a precious link to a pivotal moment in legal history.

Image Credit - BBC

King Edward I and the 1300 Confirmation

A significant part in Magna Carta's historical narrative belongs to King Edward I (who ruled 1272–1307). He reissued the charter multiple times, with the 1300 confirmation being particularly significant. This reissue occurred during his 28th regnal year. Such confirmations often happened when the monarch needed to levy new taxes or consolidate support, reinforcing the charter's principles in exchange. The 1297 reissue by Edward I was especially important as it marked the first time Magna Carta entered the Statute Rolls, the official register of English statutes.

The 1300 confirmation, the last full reissue, further cemented Magna Carta's place in English law. The careful production and dissemination of these parchments throughout the shires and to cathedrals demonstrated the Crown's commitment, at least formally, to upholding its terms. Edward I's reign saw significant legal reforms, and confirming Magna Carta anew contributed to this wider legal progression, ensuring its continued relevance.

The Role of Libraries in Preservation and Discovery

The discovery of the Harvard Magna Carta highlights the vital role of libraries and archives in preserving historical artefacts and facilitating scholarly research. The Library at Harvard Law School, possessing a vast array of rare books and manuscripts, provided the environment where HLS MS 172 remained protected, albeit unrecognised, for decades. The library's initiative to digitise its collections, including the manuscript in question, proved instrumental. This allowed Professor Carpenter remote access to the images that sparked his investigation.

The assistant dean for library services at Harvard Law School, Amanda Watson, lauded the academics for their find. She indicated it showed what transpires when institutions make collections accessible to distinguished researchers. Further, she remarked that the vital efforts of librarians underpin each scholarly discovery. Such specialists do more than gather and safeguard items; they also forge avenues to understanding that could otherwise stay concealed. The careful stewardship of such documents ensures they are available for future generations of researchers.

Technological Aids in Historical Research

Modern technology increasingly assists in the study of ancient manuscripts. As demonstrated with the Harvard Magna Carta, methods such as ultraviolet light application and spectral picture-taking prove indispensable. These methods can enhance faded script, reveal underdrawings, or differentiate inks, providing clues invisible to the unaided eye. Such non-destructive analyses allow researchers to glean more information from delicate documents without causing further degradation.

Other spectrometric methods, including infrared and Raman spectroscopy, mass spectrometry, and X-ray spectroscopy, can also analyse pigments and inks to help date or authenticate manuscripts. While radiocarbon dating can ascertain the age of the parchment or paper support, analysing the textual and material components with these advanced imaging and spectroscopic tools provides a more complete picture of a document's history and authenticity.

Magna Carta's Influence on Global Jurisprudence

Magna Carta's impact extends far beyond the shores of England. Its core principles—that the law applies to everyone, including rulers, and that individuals possess fundamental rights—have resonated through centuries and across continents. It served as a foundational inspiration for the United States Constitution and the Bill of Rights, with American founding fathers admiring its stand against monarchical overreach. Legal concepts such as due process and habeas corpus have roots in Magna Carta's provisions.

Today, numerous countries incorporate principles derived from or inspired by Magna Carta into their legal frameworks. It remains a potent symbol of liberty, the rule of law, and the ongoing struggle for human rights. The discovery of another original, particularly one residing in a prominent international academic institution, offers a fresh opportunity to engage with its enduring legacy and its relevance to contemporary discussions about governance and individual freedoms.

Image Credit - BBC

The Appleby Connection: Local Roots of a National Treasure

Appleby, a Cumbrian town, is the suspected place of origin for the Harvard Magna Carta, adding a fascinating local dimension to its story. Appleby, a former parliamentary borough, occupied an important place in medieval Westmorland. The issuance of a Magna Carta directly to such a borough underscores how these charters were not just abstract legal documents but were actively distributed to assert rights and responsibilities at a local level throughout the kingdom.

The connection to the Lowther family, historically prominent in the region, provides a plausible link in the chain of the document's custody before it reached Thomas Clarkson. Understanding the local historical context of Appleby during the 14th century and the role of families like the Lowthers can enrich our understanding of how Magna Carta was received and preserved in different parts of England. Research into local archives may yet yield further details about this specific charter's early history.

Thomas Clarkson: An Abolitionist's Charter

A connection with Thomas Clarkson (who lived 1760-1846), a leading figure in the movement to abolish the slave trade, adds another layer of historical interest. Clarkson was a dedicated campaigner for human rights and justice. His possession of a Magna Carta, a document symbolising liberty and constraints on arbitrary power, would have resonated deeply with his own ideals and work. It is plausible that such a document served as an inspiration or a tangible link to the long struggle for freedoms that he championed.

How Clarkson came to possess the Appleby Magna Carta via the Lowther family is a subject for further historical inquiry. The eventual passage of the document from his estate to AVM Forster Maynard, before proceeding to auction, highlights the often complex and sometimes serendipitous ways in which historical artefacts travel through private hands over generations before re-emerging into public knowledge.

The Auction Block: A Brief Interlude

The brief appearance of the manuscript at a Sotheby's auction in late 1945, where it sold for a mere £42 to London bookdealers Sweet & Maxwell, marks a curious point in its journey. At this stage, its actual status as an original from 1300 was evidently not recognized, evidenced by the low price and its subsequent resale to Harvard for an even smaller sum. Its depiction in the auctioneer's listing as a subsequent reproduction, 'showing some wear and moisture marks,' played a part in this low valuation.

This episode serves as a reminder that the perceived value and significance of historical items can shift dramatically based on scholarly assessment and discovery. What was once dismissed as a minor copy, sold for a nominal amount, is now recognised as an invaluable piece of world heritage. The story highlights the potential for significant finds to be overlooked, even within established markets for antiquarian items.

The Scholarly Collaboration

Successfully authenticating the Harvard Magna Carta demonstrates the power of academic collaboration. Professor Nicholas Vincent learned of Professor David Carpenter's first inkling, which arose from examining digital pictures. Their combined expertise in medieval history, Magna Carta, and palaeography (the study of old handwriting) proved crucial in piecing together the evidence. Cooperation between researchers from King's College London and experts at the University of East Anglia shows how joint investigation can yield major advancements.

Their meticulous comparison of the Harvard document with other known originals, the detailed textual analysis, and the investigation into its provenance involved a year of dedicated research. Such discoveries often rely on the deep, specialized knowledge that individual scholars cultivate over careers, combined with a willingness to share findings and test hypotheses with peers. The academic community plays a vital role in vetting and validating such claims.

Future Display and Educational Impact

The academics involved are optimistic that the public will soon view the recently confirmed Harvard Magna Carta. An exhibit of this nature would enable its core meaning and deep historical importance to gain broader recognition and esteem. For students of law, history, and political science, the opportunity to see a genuine Magna Carta dating to 1300, and to learn about its journey and rediscovery, would be an invaluable educational experience.

Professor Vincent noted the "almost providential" timing of the discovery, given contemporary discussions about liberties and constitutional traditions. The document serves as a tangible link to the historical roots of concepts like the rule of law and protection against arbitrary state action. Displaying the charter, accompanied by an explanation of its context and enduring relevance, can inspire new generations to reflect on these fundamental principles.

Challenges in Preserving Ancient Parchments

Preserving ancient documents made of parchment, an animal skin material, presents ongoing challenges. Parchment is susceptible to changes in humidity and temperature, which can cause it to shrink, warp, or become brittle. Ink can fade or flake, particularly if the document has been exposed to light or damp conditions, which the initial account of HLS MS 172 mentioned. Fire affected one of the Magna Cartas from 1215 housed in the British Library, highlighting how susceptible these unique artefacts are.

Modern conservation science employs careful climate control, specialized storage materials, and minimally invasive repair techniques to stabilize and protect such artefacts. The decision to work primarily from high-quality digital images for the initial assessment of the Harvard charter reflects a cautious approach to handling fragile originals. Ongoing vigilance and expert care are essential to ensure these windows into our past survive for centuries to come.

Magna Carta's Place in English Legal Development

Within the specific context of English legal history, Magna Carta marks a critical juncture. While not a fully formed constitution in the modern sense, it established and reaffirmed crucial legal principles that shaped the development of common law. Clauses relating to due process, lawful judgment by one's peers, and access to justice laid groundwork for future legal protections. Its repeated reissues and confirmations by Parliament reinforced its status as a fundamental part of England's legal and political landscape.

The charter was part of a longer evolution of English law, building on earlier traditions and influencing subsequent statutes like the Petition of Right (1628) and the Bill of Rights (1689). Understanding Magna Carta in its medieval context, as a product of a specific political struggle but with far-reaching implications, is key to appreciating its contribution to the distinctive trajectory of English, and subsequently British, constitutionalism.

A Renewed Appreciation

Confirming the manuscript from Harvard Law School as a genuine 1300 Magna Carta signifies more than a simple antiquarian point of interest. It is a significant event that enriches our understanding of a document that has shaped global concepts of law and liberty for over eight centuries. This 'misplaced' genuine article, acquired cheaply and remaining unnoticed, now joins the small number of enduring examples of a profoundly influential historical text. Its rediscovery underscores the enduring power of historical inquiry and the potential for remarkable finds within the quiet archives of our great institutions. The narrative surrounding HLS MS 172 offers a strong reminder that history is a living discipline, constantly open to revision and revelation.