Why Northeast Football Clubs Lack Trophies

The Enduring Trophy Question for Northeast Football 

Newcastle United’s most recent journey to a Wembley cup final brings an old puzzle back into focus: what makes it so challenging for football clubs based in the northeast to claim major honours? Across seven decades, Sunderland, Middlesbrough, and Newcastle together have lifted merely two significant domestic trophies. This sparse record invites scrutiny of the underlying elements potentially causing this lack of success. Examining the area's geography, population, and economy provides context for the difficulties these teams encounter. 

Economic & Population Factors: A Reduced Arena 

Economically, England’s northeast trails other UK areas. Data from the Office for National Statistics for 2022 ranked the northeast eleventh among eleven regions concerning Gross Domestic Product. The region's GDP is only half that recorded by the East Midlands, which sits ninth. An even starker contrast exists when comparing it to London, the leading region. The scale of the population also contributes. With 2.7 million residents, the northeast is considerably smaller than the northwest, which has 7.5 million people. Housing several prominent clubs, the northwest benefits from a substantially larger base for potential talent recruitment and exhibits a far more decorated history regarding major football silverware. 

Image Credit - NY Times

Geographic Remoteness: Challenges Posed by Distance 

Location-based issues add to the northeast's hurdles. The area's separation from England's primary economic and population hubs presents practical problems. Delays affecting the Tyne Bridge refurbishment and the closure of the Gateshead flyover exemplify infrastructure weaknesses impacting the locality. Such difficulties affect how clubs can mark successes; any victorious Newcastle return journey from Wembley, for example, cannot feature the customary Tyne Bridge procession. Steve Gibson, Middlesbrough's owner-chairman, pointed out a further geographical impediment. He noted that attracting and keeping elite managerial personnel is tough because of the northeast’s remoteness from London and other key cities. Coaches' families frequently show reluctance towards moving so distant from established social circles and conveniences. Player acquisition faces comparable barriers, hindering northeast clubs' competitiveness against teams situated in more favoured locales. 

Managerial Instability: A Hindrance to Advancement 

Regular changes in management fuel the inconsistent results seen at northeastern clubs. Collectively, the three sides have installed 48 permanent managers just since the century began. Certain appointments, viewed retrospectively, seem questionable – such as Joe Kinnear taking over at Newcastle after Kevin Keegan’s 2008 exit, Sunderland transitioning from Martin O'Neill to Paolo Di Canio during 2013, or Middlesbrough’s swift turnover involving Aitor Karanka, then Garry Monk, then Tony Pulis within 2017. This absence of steadiness obstructs the development of enduring club strategies and consistent playing identities. Frequent upheaval disrupts squad harmony and impedes player growth, making prolonged achievement hard to sustain. 

Squandered Chances: Paths Not Taken 

Beyond managerial churn, opportunities lost have marked the clubs' narratives. Consider, hypothetically, Jose Mourinho taking the reins from Sir Bobby Robson at Newcastle circa 2002. Given the club's regular participation in the Champions League plus appearances in cup semi-finals and quarter-finals then, securing a UEFA Cup or FA Cup seemed plausible. Sunderland also let chances slip regarding Brian Clough. His potential influence, perhaps mirroring his successes at Nottingham Forest or Derby County, was cut short by an unimaginative Sunderland board. Later, the club ignored Clough, selecting Lawrie McMenemy despite considerable fan backing for Clough. Sunderland further neglected Bob Paisley and Don Revie, two other significant managers from the mid-20th century; Revie had even expressed interest in the role via letter. A facility at Sunderland now carries Paisley’s name, serving as a stark emblem of that specific lost opportunity. Revie, Paisley, and Clough, all natives of the northeast, possessed extraordinary abilities both as players and managers, showed mastery in player recruitment, and led clubs towards multiple titles. 

Image Credit - NY Times

Northeast Managers: Achievement vs. Local Club Failure 

These squandered possibilities might have profoundly reshaped the fortunes of any of these northeast sides. Landing even one of these distinguished figures, particularly in an era where a manager's impact was exceptionally strong, could have catalysed a transformation. Middlesbrough opting for Jack Rowley instead of Bill Shankly provides another example of such flawed choices. Shankly, reflecting on his unsuccessful application at Middlesbrough, rued the missed chance. He felt Ayresome Park held potential akin to Anfield, the ground where he subsequently attained legendary renown with Liverpool. This recurring theme of misjudgement and lost chances highlights the difficulties northeastern teams have encountered when trying to establish lasting success. 

Decades of Letdowns: The Pursuit of Glory Persists 

Author Harry Pearson humorously summed up the prolonged frustration felt by northeast football followers, mentioning "glory-seeking" Middlesbrough fans. His publication, "The Far Corner," captures the difficulties experienced by clubs situated away from football's established power bases. Despite such issues, Middlesbrough demonstrated forward-thinking ambition by contacting a youthful Bobby Robson, born in County Durham, during his successful period managing Ipswich Town. Robson acknowledged in his autobiography that the prospect of returning to his home region tempted him, partly due to his wife's local connections. Ultimately, though, he declined, staying with Ipswich to claim the FA Cup in 1978 followed by the UEFA Cup in 1981. This situation underscores the attraction exerted by more established, successful clubs, even for managers possessing strong regional links. 

Image Credit - NY Times

A Ray of Hope: Robson's Homecoming and Improvement 

Robson did eventually come back to the northeast following Kevin Keegan's Newcastle departure in January 1997. Newcastle representatives quickly arranged a meeting with Robson in Barcelona, where he was then coaching alongside Mourinho. Sir John Hall, Newcastle's chairman at the time, successfully persuaded Robson to return. However, Robson experienced doubts while travelling back towards England, causing his actual arrival at Newcastle to be postponed until 1999. Hall later voiced regret about this postponement, pondering different scenarios had Robson begun in 1997. Before this, Hall had brought back Newcastle icon Kevin Keegan as manager. Keegan's contagious zeal and attacking football philosophy reinvigorated the club, filling the supporters with fresh optimism. Concurrently, Middlesbrough found greater stability under Steve Gibson’s guidance, while Sunderland planned for a new, more substantial stadium. Throughout the mid-to-late 1990s, signs of advancement emerged from northeast clubs. Keegan, Peter Reid, and Robson – all highly respected former England internationals – were managing the three sides. Furthermore, Keegan and Robson operated with considerable financial backing in the transfer market, exemplified by Newcastle securing local star Alan Shearer for a record £15 million fee. 

Wembley Difficulties: Close Calls and Final Disappointments 

Middlesbrough’s spending resulted in appearances at both the FA Cup and League Cup finals during 1997. Fabrizio Ravanelli netted a goal against Leicester City during extra time in the League Cup decider, only for Emile Heskey to level the score; Leicester subsequently won the replay 1-0. The lead-up to the FA Cup final versus Chelsea was troubled by internal conflict. Ravanelli argued with teammate Neil Cox regarding team selection, leading to an incident where Ravanelli spat towards Cox. Attempts by comedian Stan Boardman to ease tension on the Wembley trip offered scant comfort, as Middlesbrough succumbed 2-0, with both Chelsea goals scored by Roberto Di Matteo. A comparable outcome occurred in the 1998 League Cup final: Chelsea defeated Middlesbrough 2-0 once more, and Di Matteo was again on the scoresheet. 

Image Credit - NY Times

A Decade of Defeats: Six Finals, One Goal, Zero Trophies 

Adding Sunderland’s 1992 FA Cup final defeat, these six final losses for northeast clubs during the 1990s yielded just a solitary goal combined. Sunderland contested the 1992 FA Cup final as a Second Division team, making their run perhaps less notable than their previous Wembley visit for the 1985 League Cup final. In that earlier contest, a deflected goal from Shaun Elliott plus a missed penalty denied Sunderland the trophy, ultimately contributing to relegation after they secured victory in only one of their final twelve league fixtures. This sequence encapsulates the exasperating experiences for a generation of Sunderland followers. Newcastle United captain Geoff Nulty sustained a broken jaw shortly before the 1976 League Cup final. That injury, alongside pre-match sickness affecting the squad and Dennis Tueart's stunning overhead kick winner for Manchester City, intensified the feeling of misfortune. Tueart, whom Newcastle had released aged fifteen, had also represented Sunderland. Alan Gowling’s goal during that match stands as Newcastle’s sole contribution to the scoresheet in any major domestic cup final across nearly seven decades. 

The Northeast's Wembley Jinx: A Record of Pain 

When combined with a clear loss in the 2023 Carabao Cup final plus their FA Cup final defeat against Shankly's Liverpool side, this bleak history of losing nearly every significant Wembley cup match, scoring just once across 70 years, illustrates a deeply discouraging trend. Only a single northeast side tasted victory at Wembley throughout this span. Sunderland, guided by former Newcastle player Bob Stokoe, a Gateshead local, defied predictions by overcoming Don Revie's powerful Leeds United team 1-0 during the 1973 FA Cup final. Similar to their 1992 appearance, Sunderland competed while in the Second Division. Newcastle had previously defeated Manchester City, whose lineup included Revie, 3-1 during the 1955 FA Cup final. Stokoe recounted Revie making a dismissive comment towards him inside the Wembley tunnel prior to the 1973 final, possibly referencing their 1955 encounter when Stokoe played. Stokoe, writing in his autobiography Northern and Proud, minimised the significance of the exchange, projecting calmness. His choice of attire – a tracksuit and raincoat in case of rain – reflected a pragmatic outlook for the event. 

Image Credit - NY Times

Local Icons: Northeast Managers Dominate English Football 

Stokoe's win happened during a peak era for managers originating from the northeast. Between 1960 and 1987, managers born within a twenty-mile zone around Hetton-le-Hole (birthplace of Harry Potts) collectively secured fifteen league championships. Potts himself steered Burnley towards the title in 1960. Bob Paisley, another Hetton-le-Hole product, claimed six league titles managing Liverpool from 1976 through 1983. Harry Catterick, born in Darlington, led Everton to championship wins in 1963 and again in 1970. Revie and Clough, both hailing from Middlesbrough, captured two titles each with Leeds (1969, 1974), plus one guiding Derby (1972) and another with Nottingham Forest (1978). Howard Kendall, a Tyneside native, matched Revie's feat, winning two championships managing Everton during 1985 and 1987. This remarkable concentration of managerial prowess underscores the northeast's profound footballing legacy. 

A Golden Coaching Generation: Northeast Dominance in Cups 

Kendall also lifted the FA Cup managing Everton in 1984, adding his name to a list of fellow northeasterners like Catterick, Revie, Stokoe, and Robson who achieved that success. Robson's Everton team initiated an extraordinary sequence of six FA Cup triumphs, starting in 1966 and encompassing Lawrie McMenemy’s win with Southampton during 1976 plus Robson’s own victory leading Ipswich in 1978. After John Barnwell won the League Cup guiding Wolves in 1980, Paisley achieved an incredible trio of consecutive victories managing Liverpool between 1981 and 1983. Clough contributed two further League Cup titles with Nottingham Forest. Adding to Revie’s 1968 League Cup success leading Leeds, Jimmy Hagan, born in Sunderland, steered West Bromwich Albion to victory during 1966. Across the period from 1960 to 1987, managers originating from this compact part of England led clubs to forty-one major trophies overall, including eleven European honours and three European Cups. This tally, comparable to Glasgow's record and now challenged perhaps only by Gipuzkoa, presents a stark contrast to the achievements of northeastern clubs themselves, who can only point to Stokoe and Sunderland's FA Cup victory during this entire timeframe. 

Image Credit - NY Times

Enduring Hope: League Cup Success Provides Encouragement 

Followers of Newcastle United and Sunderland often highlight the surprising League Cup victories achieved by teams like Swindon Town, Oxford United, Luton Town, Swansea City, and Queens Park Rangers. They see these wins as proof that claiming a major trophy is feasible, even lacking a roster full of stars. Middlesbrough supporters can reference their own League Cup achievement from 2004. Under Steve McClaren's management, a side including Gareth Southgate overcame Bolton Wanderers 2-1. Although Wembley's redevelopment meant the final occurred at Cardiff's Millennium Stadium, Middlesbrough's delight was absolute, providing a brief relief from prior Wembley letdowns. Their 1997 and 1998 League Cup final defeats against Chelsea, both marked by Di Matteo goals, bracketed three straight seasons ending in final heartbreak, which included the 1997 FA Cup final loss. 

Recent Difficulties: Relegation and Final Losses Persist 

Middlesbrough's late resurgence guided by Michael Carrick, notwithstanding last season's heavy 6-1 defeat against Chelsea, has seen their attention turn towards league performance. Their demotion in 2009, followed by only one subsequent Wembley appearance (during the 2016-17 season), emphasizes the ongoing challenges. Sunderland’s 2014 League Cup final showing also concluded in defeat. Taking an early lead against Manchester City, who had recently enjoyed a 9-0 Wembley win, ultimately wasn't enough. This situation mirrored Newcastle’s final losses against exceptionally strong adversaries: Arsenal, who achieved the double in 1998, and Manchester United, who secured the treble during 1999. 

Newcastle's Latest Wembley Outing: Unfortunate Circumstances? 

Newcastle historian Paul Joannou contends that Newcastle encountered particularly formidable opponents during their 1998 and 1999 final appearances. He notes they competed against Arsenal (double winners) and Manchester United (treble winners), unlike scenarios where teams met lower-division opposition, such as Swansea City versus Bradford City in the 2013 League Cup final. This backdrop adds to Newcastle supporters' frustration regarding the 2023 Carabao Cup final loss, especially given Manchester United's potent form that season. Newcastle's backup goalkeeper, Loris Karius, started instead of Nick Pope due to suspension resulting from Pope's dismissal in the preceding league match. This contrasts with the generally smoother preparations enjoyed by other victorious teams. The circumstances affected Eddie Howe’s planning. After Newcastle's FA Cup elimination by Brighton, Howe had already started strategizing for the Carabao Cup final versus Liverpool, aware he'd lack two important players, Sven Botman and Anthony Gordon, owing to suspension. Howe termed the FA Cup defeat a hindrance, compounding existing strains on the squad. Media coverage emphasized Newcastle’s reduced squad depth, contemplating the possibility of two final defeats occurring closely together – an unusual event even within the northeast. 

Image Credit - NY Times

Renewed Prospects: Investment and Shifting Fortunes? 

Despite these recent issues, Monday’s victory over West Ham while in London provided a positive sign. Substantial financial outlays, including acquiring Italian midfielder Sandro Tonali (£55 million) and Swedish forward Alexander Isak (£62 million), indicate Newcastle is perhaps no longer positioned as an underdog. Maybe, as Bob Stokoe (Gateshead native, Newcastle's 1955 FA Cup champion, and Sunderland's 1973 FA Cup winning manager) might suggest, luck tends to favour such teams upon revered grounds like Wembley. This revived optimism highlights football's cyclical patterns, where periods of letdown can rapidly yield to fresh hope following strategic spending and encouraging outcomes. 

Northeast Football Identity: Fervour, History, and Trophy Hunger 

The football narrative of the northeast presents a complicated mix of missed chances, near successes, and brief spells of triumph. The area has yielded an extraordinary number of accomplished managers who found great success elsewhere, while the local clubs themselves frequently failed to match those achievements. This disparity underscores the distinct difficulties northeastern teams grapple with: geographical remoteness, economic constraints, and a past marked by managerial turnover. However, the supporters' fervour remains constant. The dedicated following for Newcastle, Sunderland, and Middlesbrough attests to the deeply ingrained football culture across the northeast. The clubs' histories overflow with tales of close calls and "what might have been," intensifying a powerful yearning for success. The unresolved query persists: can these clubs surmount their historical obstacles and finally establish sustained achievement back in the northeast? 

Early Influences and Football's Northeast Origins 

The northeast possesses deep footballing origins, with the area significantly contributing to the game's evolution. Charles W. Alcock, born in Sunderland and a pivotal figure during the Football Association's formative years, conceived the FA Cup and arranged the initial international football fixtures. Middlesbrough Football Club, established in 1876 by cricketers searching for a winter activity, further illustrates the region’s early adoption of football. Sunderland AFC, created in 1879 by Scottish teacher James Allan and initially named The Sunderland and District Teachers Association Football Club, points to the varied backgrounds of the area's clubs. These early figures laid the groundwork for the fervent footballing ethos that endures in the northeast today. Irrespective of the relative scarcity of major trophies, the region's input towards the sport's growth remains undeniable. 

Beyond the Premier Trio: Non-League Triumphs 

Although the "big three" frequently capture attention, non-league football flourishes throughout the northeast. Scarborough possesses the record for FA Trophy victories (three); this competition began in 1969 for semi-professional teams. Darlington, York City, Harrogate Town, plus Gateshead have also experienced success within this contest. Whitley Bay claims an impressive four FA Vase titles, widely regarded as the genuine successor to the FA Amateur Cup. Such accomplishments demonstrate the vigour and extent of football within the region, reaching beyond the professional echelons. The achievements of these non-league sides reflect ongoing passion for the game at community levels. 

Image Credit - NY Times

The Contemporary Scene: Funding, Ambition, and a Return to Glory 

Newcastle United's recent trajectory mirrors broader football dynamics: escalating investment, globalization, and the expanding sway of affluent ownership. The 2021 acquisition by Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund signalled a pivotal moment for the club, bringing substantial financial backing and elevating expectations. Eddie Howe's subsequent hiring as manager provided stability alongside a defined strategy. Howe's tactical intelligence and player development skills have reshaped Newcastle into a competitive entity. The side's qualification for the Champions League during 2023, following a two-decade absence, showed the effects of this funding and purposeful leadership. Additionally, the club ended its long wait for major domestic silverware by winning the 2024-25 EFL Cup, overcoming Liverpool 2-1 in the final. Goals credited to Dan Burn and Alexander Isak secured a momentous win for Newcastle, concluding a 56-year drought for trophies and hinting at a possible redistribution of power within English football. 

St James’ Park: A Bastion of Football Heritage 

Newcastle United's home stadium, St James’ Park, serves as an emblem of the club's lasting footprint within the city. Positioned centrally in Newcastle upon Tyne, the ground has been the stage for innumerable significant events across the club's lifespan. Holding over 52,000 spectators, St James’ Park ranks as the Premier League's seventh-largest football venue and has accommodated international fixtures, Olympic competitions, and Rugby World Cup matches. The stadium underwent significant upgrades during the late 1990s and early 2000s, bringing facilities up to date while preserving its historical character. St James’ Park signifies more than merely a football arena; it functions as a community hub, a location where successive generations of Newcastle supporters have convened to express their devotion to the club. 

Newcastle United Women: Crafting a Legacy 

The expansion of women's football is evident in Newcastle United Women's advancement. The squad earned promotion towards the Barclays Women's Championship during 2024, representing a considerable stride for the club. Funding directed towards the women's side has enabled recruitment of skilled players such as goalkeeper Claudia Moan plus former England international Demi Stokes. While the team's current objective is securing their place within the Championship, their ultimate goal involves reaching the Women’s Super League to compete at the highest tier. This development of the women's team shows a dedication to inclusivity and acknowledges women's football's increasing prominence. 

Supporter Influence: Newcastle United's Lifeblood 

The fervent backing from Newcastle United fans is celebrated across the football world. The "Toon Army" generates an energetic ambiance inside St James’ Park, offering steadfast encouragement to their team regardless of circumstances. The Newcastle United Supporters Trust (NUST) performs a crucial function representing fan viewpoints and ensuring they are acknowledged. Furthermore, the club initiated a Fan Advisory Board (FAB) during 2023 to improve dialogue between supporters and the club's administration. Such initiatives demonstrate the significance of fan interaction in contemporary football and Newcastle United's resolve to uphold a robust bond with its followers. Recent club successes have invigorated the fanbase, fostering optimism and excitement for what lies ahead. 

Difficulties and Prospects: Charting Football's Future Course 

Despite recent advancements, Newcastle United continues to encounter challenges. Sustaining success within the fiercely contested Premier League demands ongoing investment, astute player acquisition, and reliable performances. The club's new ownership model has also drawn examination, prompting inquiries about the club's future path. Departures of prominent boardroom members like Amanda Staveley and Mehrdad Ghodoussi have fuelled speculation regarding potential alterations in authority and influence at the club. Manager Eddie Howe has recognised the necessity for a supportive atmosphere to guarantee the club's continued progress. These hurdles underscore modern football's intricate environment and the requirement for meticulous foresight and strategic choices to chart the course ahead. Nonetheless, Newcastle United’s latest triumphs, combined with fervent fan backing and owner resources, point towards a promising outlook for the club. The subsequent phase in Newcastle United's story appears set to be captivating, brimming with potential and the prospect of additional success.