Orthodox Russian Church Grows Across America

The Unconventional Path: American Men, Masculinity, and the Allure of Russian Orthodoxy

A noticeable trend involves younger males in the United States affiliating with Russian Orthodox religious bodies. These churches appear to offer a powerful, unashamed expression of male identity, drawing in those feeling adrift in contemporary American society. This phenomenon, though its numbers are modest when set against major US Christian groups, points to evolving cultural and political tides. It shows a pursuit of established customs and perceived definitiveness during a period of swift societal transformation. The digital sphere plays a considerable part in this spiritual quest, linking individuals with influential leaders and communities of similar belief.

The Quest for Potent Manliness

Digital platforms showcase clerics advocating for a vigorous, assertive vision of manhood. One prominent individual, Father Moses McPherson, a clergyman based in Texas, often discusses methods for men to significantly boost their masculine characteristics to remarkable extents. His online presentations frequently find fault with current societal behaviours he views as excessively effeminate. He criticizes items like form-fitting trousers, the posture of crossed legs, the domestic task of ironing clothes, meticulous eyebrow shaping, and also the partaking of broths. Such critiques find an audience among men who feel estranged by shifting gender paradigms and societal pressures in Western nations.

A Roofer's Journey to an Orthodox Altar

Father Moses McPherson, a sturdily-formed parent of five children, cuts an impressive figure. He frequently appears in online videos engaging in weightlifting, often with a background of powerful rock anthems. His formative years involved a Protestant education, and he previously earned his livelihood laying roofs. At present, he holds a clerical position within the Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia (ROCOR). This body has a presence in the Texas community of Georgetown. ROCOR represents an extension from the principal ecclesiastical authority based in Moscow. His personal evolution and authoritative demeanour attract individuals looking for strong guiding examples.

ROCOR's Growing Footprint in America

ROCOR, an international organisation with its central administrative functions based within New York City, has lately experienced a period of growth in diverse American locales. This expansion primarily arises from individuals who adopt this belief system having moved away from different spiritual traditions or from a secular background. The church's commitment to traditionalism and its perceived genuineness serve as potent attractions. For some, ROCOR presents a clear alternative to what they consider the weakened or excessively liberal tendencies of other Christian groups in America. This development suggests a distinct kind of spiritual searching.

Image Credit - Freepik

Texan Congregation Sees Rapid Expansion

Over the most recent half-year, seventy-five fresh adherents have undergone preparation for their christening under the guidance of Father Moses. This occurs at his parish, named the Mother of God, situated a short distance northwards from Austin. He recalls that two decades prior, when he and his partner adopted this faith, Orthodoxy remained largely obscure; they frequently termed it a closely held treasure. Nevertheless, he points to a significant change, observing that in the span of the most recent eighteen months, the attendance at his church has grown threefold. This swift multiplication underscores a rising curiosity about this particular form of worship.

Young Males Drawn to Ancient Rites

Attending Sunday worship at the church Father Moses leads, one observes a notable quantity of males, typically within their third or fourth decade of life, devoutly participating in worship. They make reverent gestures towards the rear of the main church hall. This venerable spiritual path, with its practices extending to the fourth century CE, appears to possess a distinct attraction for younger men who find themselves disquieted by aspects of modern American existence. The formalised divine service and deep historical roots provide a feeling of steadiness and connection that some perceive as absent in today's world.

Finding Purpose Amidst Modern Unease

Theodore, who works as a software developer, recounted his own story. Despite possessing a desirable professional life and a spouse he deeply valued, he felt a significant internal emptiness, a palpable deficiency in his being. He contends that current societal attitudes have dealt men an unfairly harsh hand, persistently suggesting their culpability. Theodore voices frustration over males receiving censure for aspiring to fulfil the role of principal household earner, enabling their partners to concentrate on domestic responsibilities. This feeling of unjust condemnation or marginalisation is a recurrent theme among certain new adherents.

Questioning Contemporary Relationship Ideals

Theodore articulated his dissatisfaction with widespread societal perspectives on conventional family arrangements. He observed that the societal model of men acting as principal earners, thereby supporting a wife dedicated to homemaking, often receives labels like a "decidedly detrimental arrangement" within modern discussions, according to Theodore. He strongly maintains this characterisation is erroneous and that such family structures ought to possess validity and command respect. This inclination to preserve established gender roles within the marital bond is a key motivator for numerous men attracted to ROCOR. These men frequently look for a religious structure that validates these more traditional home life patterns.

Domestic Education: A Central Choice

A great majority of recent adherents make the decision to educate their young ones at home. This preference stems, in part, from a belief that females should place family obligations before professional aspirations. Moreover, home-based learning permits parents to instil their religious tenets directly and to buffer their offspring from public education systems they find objectionable. They consider it a method to foster a particular ethical and spiritual atmosphere for their children, insulated from worldly influences they find untrustworthy. These choices reflect a deep commitment to specific moral frameworks.

Image Credit - Freepik

Shielding Youth via Home Learning

An archpriest, Father John Whiteford, based in Spring, a community north of the Houston urban area and affiliated with ROCOR, advocates for home instruction. He asserts this method guarantees religious teaching and operates as "a shield for their offspring." He further explains that such an educational route helps bypass school discussions concerning subjects he described as concepts of gender alteration or the numerous gender classifications discussed in current times. This viewpoint underscores a profound apprehension among these parents regarding cultural evolutions in gender identity and sex education, leading them to shield their children from such topics.

Orthodox Adherence: Numerically Small, Culturally Resonant

When contrasted with the many millions attending worship in America's large-scale evangelical congregations, followers of Christian Orthodoxy are comparatively few, representing roughly just one per cent of the nation's populace. This broad category encompasses The Eastern Orthodox tradition, evident in places like Russia, Ukraine, various Eastern European countries, and Greece. Additionally, it includes Oriental Orthodox practices that have their roots in Middle Eastern and African areas. Despite their smaller demographic footprint, this faith community is gaining increased visibility and articulateness, especially certain elements within it. Their cultural impact might thus exceed what their numbers alone would suggest.

ROCOR: A Traditionalist Stronghold

Religious figures and priests escaping the upheaval of the 1917 Russian Revolution were instrumental in establishing ROCOR. Numerous commentators regard this body as the Orthodox authority in the United States that most stringently adheres to established teachings. This comparatively small spiritual group is notably expressive. The internal developments within ROCOR are indicative of more extensive political transformations, particularly subsequent to the notable alteration in policy towards Moscow by former President Donald Trump. The church's unwavering adherence to tradition appeals to individuals apprehensive about liberalising movements in other religious institutions and broader society.

Growing Male Presence in Orthodox Circles

To accurately measure the upturn in individuals adopting this faith proves challenging. Nevertheless, figures compiled by the Pew Research Centre provide some illumination. This data indicates that sixty-four per cent of Orthodox Christians currently identify as male. This figure represents a significant rise from the forty-six per cent recorded in the year 2007. Such a demographic alteration, pointing towards a more pronounced male majority, suggests a particular appeal of this faith tradition to men in the recent past. Ongoing scholarly work continues to delve into the factors contributing to this gender disparity in conversion rates to Orthodoxy.

Pandemic Influences on Male Conversions

A more limited investigation involving 773 individuals who changed their faith seems to corroborate the pattern of greater male affiliation. This particular piece of research suggests that the majority of recent entrants into this faith are men. A considerable number of these male converts have indicated that the worldwide health crisis served as an impetus, compelling them to explore an alternative spiritual conviction. The Orthodox Church in America (OCA) supplied the information for this particular poll. Figures from Russian monastic orders initiated the OCA's presence in Alaska towards the latter part of the eighteenth century.

Image Credit - Freepik

OCA's North American Expansion

The Orthodox Church in America (OCA) currently sustains a notable presence, encompassing upwards of 700 local churches, outreach programmes, and congregational groups. Furthermore, it administers monastic houses and diverse organisations across the United States, Canada, and also Mexico. These various bodies all acknowledge an alignment with Russian Orthodoxy. The OCA’s foundational history connects back to Russian efforts to spread Christianity in Alaska. Its ongoing development and the steady stream of new members point to a lasting interest in this specific offshoot of Eastern Christianity throughout the North American landmass.

Cincinnati Parish Experiences Overwhelming Growth

An academic, Professor Scott Kenworthy, who investigates the historical development and theological ideas within Eastern Orthodox Christianity, with a particular emphasis on contemporary Russia, reports a remarkable situation. He describes his own OCA parish situated in Cincinnati as being "absolutely filled to its limits." Having been a member of this same church community for a period of twenty-four years, he notes that attendance levels at the church were generally stable up until the societal restrictions imposed during the COVID-19 pandemic. Since that juncture, a continuous influx of new individuals expressing interest and those making ready for their formal induction through baptism; these individuals are termed catechumens, has become apparent, signalling a profound change.

A Trend Extending Beyond Localities

Professor Kenworthy maintains that this heightened curiosity is not a mere local anomaly. He clarifies this particular situation is not confined solely to his individual congregation, nor is it restricted to a small number of locations within Texas. On the contrary, he posits that "it is unquestionably a phenomenon of a more extensive nature." This assessment from a scholarly figure highlights that the increase in Orthodox conversions, especially notable among males, constitutes a more generalised pattern observable in various geographical areas. This development calls for a more thorough investigation into its root causes and wider societal ramifications.

The Impact of the Digital Sanctuary

The online environment holds considerable significance in this current surge of recent adherents. Father Moses, for example, commands a significant online audience. When he shares personal information, like a photograph of a successful pregnancy indicator on his Instagram page declaring the forthcoming arrival of his sixth baby, he garners thousands of affirmative responses. This form of digital interaction showcases the efficacy of social media platforms in connecting with prospective converts and fostering a sense of community beyond the confines of conventional church structures. Online avenues provide ease of access and a direct communication channel to influential personalities.

Devotion to God: Celibacy or Matrimony

Father Moses instructs his assembly that two principal avenues exist for dedicating one's life to divine service. The initial route entails embracing a monastic existence, either as a man committing to monasticism or a woman to a nunnery. The other option includes entering into matrimony. For individuals who opt for the latter, he strongly counsels against employing contraceptive methods. Instead, he urges them to aspire to welcome the greatest quantity of offspring they can. This guidance is in harmony with long-standing Christian perspectives on procreation and the structure of family life, often presenting a contrast to contemporary secular viewpoints.

Image Credit - Freepik

Stance Against Birth Prevention and Self-Gratification

Father Moses voices staunch opposition to any form of contraception. He challenges his listeners to identify a single revered figure from the Church's past who ever sanctioned such interventions. Concerning the act of masturbation—a practice the church designates as "self-defilement"—the priest delivers an unambiguous condemnation. He describes the act as "regrettable and not fitting for a man." These resolute positions on matters of individual conduct and sexual morality are typical of the traditionalist doctrines that draw certain people seeking unambiguous moral guidance and a repudiation of what they perceive as the moral ambiguity of the present day.

Orthodoxy as "Standard," The West as "Over-feminised"

Father Moses suggests Orthodoxy is "not specifically masculine; it represents normality." He contrasts this with his observation that, "in Western culture, a pervasive feminisation has occurred." It is his conviction that certain Protestant ecclesiastical bodies have become disproportionately geared towards appealing primarily to women. This viewpoint intimates a sense that mainstream Western cultural norms, and even some forms of religious practice, have deviated from a traditional equilibrium, thereby spurring a quest for what he terms a more "standard," historically anchored form of masculinity and spiritual life.

Disdain for "Pop Concert" Worship Experiences

Articulating his aversion to particular contemporary worship formats, Father Moses declared his lack of interest in attending worship events that "create the atmosphere of a Taylor Swift show." He finds fault with the wording found in some contemporary "adoration songs," deeming it "exclusively about feelings," a characteristic he contends fails to connect with men. This criticism underscores a preference for more conventional, dignified, and perhaps more intellectually demanding styles of worship, as opposed to services perceived as being centred on emotional responses or having an entertainment-like quality.

New Adherents and the "Anti-Progressive" Identity

Having previously been a Protestant, Elissa Bjeletich Davis now affiliates with the Austin Greek Orthodox Church; she acts as a Sunday catechist and produces her own audio programme. She has noticed that a significant number of individuals embracing this faith also align themselves with what she calls "the anti-modernisation faction." Davis points out that these recent members occasionally harbour "peculiar perspectives" concerning their adopted religious system, particularly individuals who join the Russian Church. This observation indicates a possible convergence between religious conversion and wider socio-political belief systems, where faith becomes enmeshed with a rejection of progressive social ideals.

Imagining a "Masculine, Hierarchical Faith"

Further commenting on convert perceptions, Elissa Bjeletich Davis notes some new adherents perceive the Russian Orthodox Church as "a martial, inflexible, disciplined, male-centric, and power-based religion." She regards this interpretation as "somewhat amusing." It is almost, she humorously suggests, as if "bygone American Puritan individuals and their distinctive oddities are making a comeback." This illustrates how pre-existing beliefs or particular longings for defined order and authority can influence the manner in which people understand and adopt a new religious framework, sometimes in ways that appear out of step with current times.

An Unexpected Welcome

Buck Johnson, who has dedicated a quarter of a century to firefighting and also produces the Counterflow sound program, recounted his first encounters with Russian Orthodoxy. He conceded to an initial apprehension about stepping into his nearby Russian Orthodox ecclesiastical building, feeling he "presented an atypical appearance, adorned with many tattoos." Despite this, he informed the interviewer of the remarkably open welcome he encountered. This open-armed acceptance, notwithstanding his non-traditional appearance, profoundly influenced his choice to delve deeper into the faith. It points towards a level of inclusiveness that might seem at odds with the church's outwardly stern reputation.

Church Accessibility During Pandemic Noted

An additional element that made a positive impact on Buck Johnson was the church's choice to continue operations throughout the Covid-19 societal restrictions. For certain individuals, the readiness of particular religious establishments to maintain in-person gatherings, even when faced with public health directives to the contrary, signified a steadfast dedication to their faith and community. This approach stood in contrast to other institutions that temporarily ceased physical services, a course of action that distanced some of their attendees. Johnson's favourable impression suggests this was a compelling factor for him and potentially for others as well.

Image Credit - Freepik

Faith Reshaping Global Perspectives

Living in the town of Lockhart, Buck Johnson mused on how his recently embraced religious beliefs are transforming his outlook on international affairs. While seated on a sofa positioned before two very large television displays, he made specific reference to his escalating unease regarding "unfavourable American perceptions concerning Russia." He holds the conviction that established, or "traditional," news organisations frequently provide a skewed portrayal of intricate geopolitical situations, citing the military conflict in Ukraine as an example. This indicates that his spiritual conversion is closely linked with a reassessment of dominant political narratives.

Scrutinising Anti-Russian Narratives

Buck Johnson provided more detail on his doubts regarding the widespread negative sentiment towards Russia within the United States. He opined, "I believe a residual attitude persists among the post-war generation within America, people who lived during the period of East-West tension." He further remarked, "and I do not fully understand the basis for it—yet they consistently assert that Russia is inherently detrimental." This challenging of entrenched geopolitical beliefs mirrors a more extensive pattern among certain people who are re-evaluating historical accounts and current media depictions, often guided by alternative sources of information and their newly adopted faith communities.

Interpreting Patriarch Kirill's Stance

Patriarch Kirill, the leading authority of the Russian Church headquartered in Moscow, has steadfastly supported the military engagement in Ukraine. He terms it a divine conflict and shows scant sympathy for the casualties. Numerous commentators regard Patriarch Kirill as a proponent of warfare. When questioned about Russia's foremost cleric, Archpriest Father John Whiteford gave an assurance that the Patriarch's declarations were misrepresented. This act of defence underscores a notable variance in how the Patriarch’s role and declarations are understood, especially among ROCOR followers.

Putin: A Symbol for Christian Traditionalists?

Visual recordings and still images often capture Vladimir Putin referencing scriptural passages. He is seen clutching tapers at worship within Moscow's Cathedral of Christ the Saviour. Furthermore, he takes part in the Epiphany tradition of plunging into frozen water. These portrayals appear to resonate profoundly with particular individuals, both within the United States and in different countries. These individuals tend to view Russia, under Putin's governance, as the final bulwark of genuine Christian belief, a protector of established moral principles against what they perceive as an encroaching wave of Western secularism and liberal ideologies.

The Texan Cleric's Russian Relocation

Close to ten years ago, another Orthodox new adherent who became a clergyman, Father Joseph Gleason, made a substantial life change. He left America, specifically Texas, and established a home in Borisoglebskiy. This rural community lies about a four-hour car trip northward from the Russian capital. His wife and their eight young ones accompanied him. This decision signifies a deep-seated devotion to his chosen faith and a yearning to reside in a societal context he feels is more in step with his traditional Christian tenets.

Russia's Draw: Conventional Values and Deep History

Explaining his motivations to a Russian digital media host, Father Joseph Gleason highlighted that Russia, in his view, "disallows homosexual marriage and does not offer legal status to civil unions." He praised the nation as "a setting where home-based learning for children is possible." Crucially, he added, "and, naturally, my admiration for the millennium-long history of Orthodox Christianity in this land is immense." These remarks highlight the attraction of Russia's conservative social framework and its extensive Orthodox historical background for certain Western individuals holding traditionalist views.

An Emigration Movement Emerges

Father Joseph Gleason, this Texan clergyman notable for his slight beard, is prominent within an initiative that encourages conservative people and their families to make Russia their home. This effort portrays Russia as a sanctuary from the perceived excesses of Western progressive thought. In August of the preceding calendar year, Mr Putin initiated a streamlined "common ideals" visa system. This specific visa is designed for individuals wishing to depart from Western nations due to fundamental disagreements with dominant social and political currents, providing them a more direct route to establishing residency within Russia.

Spurning US Consumerism for Lasting Ideals

While back in his home state of Texas, Buck Johnson explained that he, along with his fellow new believers, consciously rejects what they see as the superficiality of quick fixes and the pervasive materialist ethos in America. He underscored a change in their priorities. Buck Johnson stated, "We are now focusing on enduring matters." This forward-looking viewpoint gives prominence to principles such as time-honoured customs, profound familial affection, a robust dedication to one's local surroundings, and sincere goodwill towards those living nearby.

Orthodoxy's Resonance in the Texan Milieu

Buck Johnson offered a concluding thought on how well Orthodoxy aligns with individuals such as himself, especially when considering the cultural backdrop of Texas. He expressed his opinion that "Orthodoxy aligns well with our group—and this holds particular relevance in the Texan context." This suggests that the tenets promoted by this particular segment of Orthodox Christianity—which include ideals like self-sufficiency, a strong community orientation, and an adherence to tradition—connect with certain identifiable characteristics of Texan identity and the wider conservative cultural ethos of the American South.

The Magnetism of Unchanging Beliefs

For numerous men, the constant character of Orthodox teaching, which its advocates assert has stayed largely unaltered for close to two thousand years, presents a significant draw. In a global context marked by fluctuating ethical standards and developing societal customs, the church's unwavering commitment to age-old declarations of faith and established rituals can seem like a beacon of firmness. This apparent steadfastness offers a stark contrast to certain Western religious groups that have modified their positions on diverse social topics, a trend viewed unfavourably by these new adherents who are in search of enduring verities.

Masculine Expressions in Worship and Custom

The forms of worship within Orthodoxy frequently give prominence to solemnity, deep respect, and a certain degree of physical discipline. The practice of standing for extended services, the act of making full prostrations, and the largely male composition of the clergy all contribute to an atmosphere that some who have converted perceive as fundamentally more masculine than typical contemporary Protestant gatherings. The rich sensory engagement involving incense, liturgical chanting, and religious imagery also cultivates a unique environment that appeals to those looking for a more deeply felt and historically grounded type of spiritual observance, setting it apart from modern, emotion-centric praise singing.

Digital Fellowships and Confirmation Bias

The internet functions not merely as a first point of contact but also cultivates continuous participation and the formation of communities. Online discussion boards, groups on social media platforms, and video channels devoted to Orthodox traditionalism permit new members and those exploring the faith to establish connections, relate personal experiences, and strengthen their mutual convictions. While offering valuable support, these digital environments can also inadvertently become spaces where similar viewpoints are constantly reinforced. Dissenting opinions may be downplayed, and a specific interpretation regarding faith, male identity, and societal deterioration can be amplified, potentially fostering a more rigid ideological stance.

Geopolitical Leanings and Spiritual Selfhood

For one portion of these new adherents, embracing Russian Orthodoxy connects with a wider affinity for Russia as a significant international actor. They might consider Russia a protective barrier against trends of globalism and what they see as moral decline in Western nations. This viewpoint often includes a critical assessment of Western nations' foreign policies and the narratives presented by media outlets concerning Russia. Consequently, their spiritual self-identification becomes closely linked with a distinct geopolitical stance. In this framework, religious commitment and political views tend to bolster one another, culminating in a comprehensive personal philosophy.

ROCOR's Approach to Inter-Church Relations

ROCOR has, throughout its history, adopted a guarded, and on occasion critical, posture concerning ecumenism—the initiative aimed at fostering unity among various Christian denominations. This stance is attractive to individuals who hold the conviction that other ecclesiastical bodies have significantly deviated from foundational Christian doctrines. For these individuals, ROCOR’s unwavering claim to embody authentic Orthodox practice offers a feeling of distinctiveness and doctrinal soundness; their aim is not interdenominational discussion but engagement with what they see as the pure, original form of Christian teachings.

Navigating the Convert's Path: Demands and Adjustments

Although the attraction is considerable, the journey of an individual converting to Russian Orthodoxy presents its own set of difficulties. The demanding schedules for fasting, the extended duration of religious services, and the necessity of acquiring a new cultural and theological lexicon can prove quite challenging. Moreover, becoming integrated into well-established parish communities, which frequently possess deep-rooted ethnic connections (for instance, to Russian or Eastern European immigrant groups and their subsequent generations), can at times be a gradual undertaking for American-born converts lacking that specific ancestral background. Successfully managing these various elements requires a substantial level of dedication.

Future Outlooks and Broader Social Relevance

The pattern of young American men adopting Russian Orthodoxy, though currently representing a movement of limited scale, justifies continued careful study. Its subsequent development might be influenced by a range of elements. These include the changing socio-political environments within both the US and Russia, the persistent sway of influential figures in the online sphere, and the capacity of ROCOR and OCA parishes to effectively incorporate and hold onto these new congregants. While its numbers are not vast, this development intersects with more extensive societal dialogues concerning concepts of masculinity, the role of tradition, questions of religious liberty, and the fundamental human pursuit of significance in the twenty-first century.