Young Men Battle Rising Mental Health Crisis in Britain

The Unseen Struggle: Why British Boys Are Falling Behind

Evidence across schooling, psychological well-being, and the path to maturity suggests a growing number of young men in the United Kingdom face considerable hurdles. While their female counterparts frequently advance, a significant cohort of boys appears to be faltering, prompting urgent questions about the societal and systemic factors at play.

Across the span of their development, young males in Britain encounter a series of challenges that signal a worrying trend. From their earliest school days through to their entry into the workforce and adult life, indicators point towards a divergence in fortunes compared to young women. This is not a fleeting observation but a pattern substantiated by a growing body of information. Researchers and social commentators highlight a confluence of economic and cultural shifts that have reshaped the landscape for young males.

Educational settings have, in some ways, become environments where girls more readily excel. Simultaneously, the labour market has transformed, with a decline in traditionally male-dominated industries and a rise in service sector roles often filled by women. Compounding these structural changes are evolving societal narratives around masculinity, with some young men reporting feelings of confusion and a lack of clear direction. This article will examine the evidence illuminating the challenges confronting Britain's young men and explore the complex reasons behind this growing disparity.

Educational Headwinds: Early Years and Primary Schooling

The educational journey for many boys in the UK begins with a discernible disadvantage. By the end of the reception year, at around age five, a smaller proportion of boys achieve a 'good level of development' compared to girls. In the 2022-23 academic year, just under two-thirds of boys reached this benchmark, contrasted with approximately three-quarters of girls. This initial gap often persists and, within certain localities, widens as children progress through primary education. For instance, by the close of primary schooling in the same academic year, 63% of girls met the expected standard in all three core areas of English reading, writing, and mathematics, whereas only 56% of boys did so.

While boys demonstrated slightly better performance in mathematics alone, with 73% meeting the standard compared to 72% of girls, their overall attainment in foundational literacy and numeracy skills lagged. These early discrepancies in educational outcomes can have long-lasting implications, potentially influencing future academic pathways and confidence in learning. The reasons for these early differences are multifaceted, with researchers pointing to developmental variations, teaching styles, and curriculum emphasis as possible contributing factors.

Image Credit - Freepik

The Widening Gap: Secondary School and GCSE Performance

As boys transition into secondary education, the attainment disparities observed in earlier years tend to become more pronounced. Statistics for the 2022/23 academic year show that girls continued to outperform boys across all headline measures at GCSE level. For example, 68% of girls in state-funded schools achieved a grade 4 or above in both English and maths GCSEs, compared to 63% of boys. Looking at higher grades, 24.9% of female entries achieved a grade 7 or A, while the figure for male entries was 19.1% in 2022/23.

Although this particular gap for top grades was the narrowest it had been in 14 years, a significant difference still remained. It is important to note, however, that the gender gap in GCSE results has seen some narrowing in recent years. For instance, in 2019, the gap for grade 5 and above in Maths and English was 6.6%, reducing to 5.7% in 2022. Despite this slight closure, girls maintain an overall advantage. Reports indicated that in 2023, boys were 4.5 months behind girls when averaging across GCSE grades in English and maths, though this was an improvement from 5 months in 2022 and the smallest gap since relevant data series began in 2011.

Disciplinary Disparities and Special Educational Needs

Beyond academic results, boys are disproportionately represented in school disciplinary figures. During the autumn term of the 2022/23 academic year, official data indicated that the likelihood of boys facing suspension from school was almost double that for girls. The disparity was even starker for permanent exclusions, with boys being slightly more than twice as likely to be permanently excluded. Such disciplinary actions can significantly disrupt a student's education and long-term prospects. Furthermore, boys are more frequently identified as having special educational needs. In January 2023, 22% of boys had identified SEN, compared to 12% of girls.

A higher percentage of boys, 6%, had Education, Health and Care plans, which indicate more complex special educational needs, compared to 2% of girls. Research also suggests that unrecognized ADHD may contribute to the higher rates of school exclusion among boys. Some studies show boys are more prone to hyperactive behaviours, while girls with ADHD may be more likely to present with inattentive symptoms, potentially leading to underdiagnosis in girls.

Post-16 Education and University Entry

The trend of female students outperforming males continues into post-16 education and progression to university. At A-Level, while the gender gap has decreased somewhat in recent years, girls still generally achieve better results. In 2021 A-Level results, 46.4% of female students achieved A* or A grades, compared to 41.7% for boys. Although in 2023, analysis noted the 16-19 gender gap was at its narrowest since relevant records began in 2017, female students still achieved around a grade and a half more highly than male students across their best three qualifications.

This pattern has significant implications for higher education. Men are considerably less likely to progress to higher education by age 19 than women. In the 2021/22 academic year, 54% of women were in higher education by this age, compared to only 40% of men. This gap had slightly increased from the previous year. Higher education statistics for 2022/23 showed 1,668,600 female higher education students compared to 1,251,815 male students in the UK. Men are also more likely to drop out of their university courses.

Image Credit - Freepik

Factors Influencing Educational Disparities

Numerous factors likely contribute to these persistent educational disparities. Some researchers suggest that the structure and focus of modern schooling may inadvertently favour learning styles more commonly associated with girls. Dominant norms of masculinity for boys at school often involve expectations of 'hardness', sporting prowess, and a casual approach to academic work, which can conflict with educational engagement. Peer group pressure can discourage boys from appearing studious. Away from these pressures, boys can be more reflective.

Concerns have been highlighted about the underachievement of boys, suggesting a need for a "boy-positive" learning environment in schools and even proposing dedicated governmental focus to address gender disparities. The curriculum, assessment methods, and a shortage of male role models in the teaching profession, particularly in primary schools, are also frequently cited as areas for consideration. Addressing these complex issues requires a multi-faceted approach, from early years interventions to reforms at secondary and higher education levels. Governmental commitment aims to raise attainment for all pupils, regardless of gender, through various initiatives.

The Mental Health Crisis Among Young Men

Young men in the UK face significant and distinct mental health challenges. While the psychological well-being of youths overall has seen a decline, male youths encounter particular difficulties. Previous data indicated a higher percentage of boys aged 3 to 17 had a psychological, emotive, conduct-related, or growth-related issue, contrasting with girls. Practitioners have reported increasing mental health concerns among young people since the COVID-19 pandemic, with new serious issues arising from lack of prevention, social isolation, and anxiety about the future.

Research has revealed that almost half of young men (18-34) in the UK felt reluctant to discuss their feelings for fear of appearing less masculine. This aligns with societal expectations for men to be "emotionally strong" and not show weakness. Such pressures can lead to bottling up emotions, which is detrimental to mental wellbeing. Indeed, a survey in 2022 found that 52% of UK men felt pressured by societal expectations, with 40% suffering anxiety as a result. A concerning 34% of men under 35 felt that struggling with mental health made them less masculine.

Specific Conditions and Behavioural Manifestations

Boys receive diagnoses for Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder and autism at significantly higher rates than girls in the UK. For ADHD, boys account for 75% of diagnoses, and for autism, it is 71%. While diagnostic biases may play a role, with conditions potentially being less frequently identified in female youths, as their manifestations can differ, the disparity in diagnosed cases is substantial. Experts suggest that since male youths frequently encounter societal pressures for emotional composure, their internal difficulties more often manifest through their actions rather than through verbalised anxiety or depression, which are more commonly diagnosed in girls.

This can lead to boys being labelled as disruptive. The pressure to "man up" remains a powerful societal expectation for over half of young men. This reluctance to show vulnerability can mean that underlying mental health issues go unaddressed until they reach a crisis point. The consequences of these unaddressed struggles can be severe, impacting educational attainment, social relationships, and overall life trajectory.

Friendship, Support, and the Tragedy of Suicide

The perceived need to maintain a tough exterior can also affect young men's social support networks. While many teenage boys report having friends they can rely on, the proportion is lower than for girls. This potential deficit in close, emotionally supportive friendships can leave young men feeling more isolated when facing difficulties. The most tragic consequence of poor mental health among young men is the high rate of self-inflicted death. This remains the biggest cause of mortality for men under the age of 45 in the UK. Statistics consistently show that self-inflicted death occurs much more frequently in adult males compared to adult females.

The rise in such rates among the younger demographic has disproportionately impacted young adult males. This devastating reality underscores the urgent need for more effective mental health support tailored to the specific needs and communication styles of male youths. Services must acknowledge and address the societal pressures that discourage help-seeking. Fostering environments where emotional expression is not seen as a weakness is crucial.

Image Credit - Freepik

Delayed Transitions: Navigating Adulthood

The journey to traditional markers of adulthood is becoming longer for many young people in the UK. While young individuals collectively in Britain are experiencing a lengthier period to achieve conventional markers of maturity, this phenomenon appears especially evident among young adult males. One significant indicator is the increasing number of young men continuing to reside with their parental figures. Figures from 2021 showed that adult children living with their parents had increased by 14.7% since 2011, with 60.8% of these adult children being male.

More recent analysis from 2023-24 indicated that 23% of men aged 25-34 lived at a parental home, compared with 15% of women in the same age group. At age 25, nearly half of men (49%) lived with their parents. Factors such as increased housing costs, the precarious nature of the youth labour market, and changing social norms contribute to this phenomenon. While living at home can offer financial relief, it may also delay the development of independent living skills and financial autonomy for some.

Shifting Sands in the Labour Market

The world of work has undergone substantial transformations that have distinctly affected young men's employment trajectories. There has been a notable decline in traditionally male-dominated sectors, such as manufacturing and manual labour, particularly in post-industrial areas of the UK. Conversely, the service-oriented economy has expanded, with women often dominating these roles. This structural shift has contributed to a steady decline in the labour force participation rate for men, while women's participation has climbed.

In the UK, the male labour force participation rate has seen a decline, influenced by these changes in industry, as well as differences in educational attainment and health issues. Recent data indicates a rise in young men being out of work due to illness or disability, a figure that has more than doubled since 2000. Furthermore, the number of young people not in employment, education, or training (NEET) due to ill health has substantially increased, with mental ill health reports quintupling between 2005 and 2024 for this group.

Economic Inactivity and Future Prospects

The rise in economic inactivity among young men, particularly due to long-term sickness, is a growing concern. The UK has seen an increase in workers becoming economically inactive due to long-term sickness, with stress and mental health being major contributors. For young males specifically, being NEET can lead to feelings of hopelessness. Almost one in five young NEET individuals reported having a mental health condition in 2023. These employment challenges can, in turn, affect other aspects of adulthood, such as forming independent households and starting families.

And although adult females continue to receive lower average remuneration than adult males, the disparity in pay has been diminishing, and the typical earnings for females have ascended more substantially than for males in recent decades. The evolving economic landscape appears, in some respects, to be less aligned with traditional male roles and skills, presenting new challenges for young men striving for financial stability and career progression. These trends highlight a need for better support for young men navigating a complex and changing job market, including reskilling opportunities and mental health support to address economic inactivity.

The Influence of Masculinity and Societal Expectations

Societal expectations surrounding masculinity play a significant role in shaping young men's experiences and choices. Many young men report feeling pressure to conform to a dominant masculine stereotype, which often includes being strong, stoic, financially successful, and avoiding any display of vulnerability. These expectations can be internalised from a young age and reinforced by peers, media, and sometimes even family.

Research indicates that many young men feel that society still expects them to be the primary breadwinner, and that an inability to provide financially can lead to feelings of emasculation. This pressure can be particularly acute in an economic climate where stable, well-paying jobs traditionally held by men are less prevalent. The perceived need to "man up" when facing challenges can prevent young men from seeking help for mental health issues, academic difficulties, or employment struggles, as this might be seen as a sign of weakness. This reluctance to express vulnerability can exacerbate problems, leading to a cycle of silence and struggle.

Image Credit - Freepik

Navigating Shifting Gender Roles

While there is a general acceptance among many young men that increasing gender equality is positive, and a belief in treating women as equals, traditional stereotypes about male and female roles still hold considerable power. Some young men articulate a sense of disadvantage associated with being male, contrasting this with the high expectations placed upon them. The discourse around "toxic masculinity" has also entered public consciousness. While intended to critique harmful aspects of traditional masculinity, some young men may feel that masculinity itself is being broadly condemned, leading to confusion or resentment.

Expectations of 'being a man' can lead some young males towards serious violent crime, with pressure to uphold a masculine image based on strength being intensified by social media. This involves suppressing emotions other than aggression and rejecting anything perceived as feminine. Helping young men navigate these complex and sometimes contradictory messages about what it means to be a man today is crucial.

The Critical Need for Positive Male Role Models

Positive male role models are vital in helping boys and young men develop healthy identities and navigate societal pressures. Role models can be family members, teachers, coaches, mentors, or even public figures who embody qualities such as kindness, respect, emotional intelligence, and resilience. They demonstrate that strength can coexist with vulnerability and that seeking help is a sign of courage, not weakness.

Observing men who manage their emotions in healthy ways and treat others with respect can counteract negative stereotypes about masculinity. In an educational context, the presence of more male teachers, particularly in primary schools, could provide boys with relatable figures and challenge gendered perceptions of learning and career paths. Initiatives to train young male mentors in schools to combat negative attitudes and promote respect are also valuable. These everyday influencers can play a powerful part in shaping positive behaviours and aspirations.

Promoting Healthy Masculinity and Support Systems

Fostering healthy concepts of masculinity involves encouraging a wider range of acceptable behaviours and emotional expression for male youths. It means creating environments where they feel safe to be themselves, to struggle, and to ask for support without fear of judgement. This requires a collective effort from families, schools, communities, and policymakers. Schools can play a role by promoting inclusive learning environments and curricula that reflect diverse experiences of masculinity. Community programmes that offer mentorship and support for young males are also important.

Ensuring accessible and destigmatised mental health services tailored to the requirements of young males is paramount. Furthermore, addressing the structural economic factors that disproportionately affect young men, such as the decline of certain industries and the need for new skills, is essential. Encouraging men to enter a wider range of professions, including those traditionally dominated by women like teaching and care roles, can also challenge stereotypes and open up new opportunities.

Addressing Systemic Disadvantage: Class and Ethnicity

It is crucial to acknowledge that the challenges facing male youths are not uniform. Socioeconomic background and ethnicity significantly intersect with gender to create compounded disadvantages for certain groups. For instance, boys from lower-income families and some ethnic minority backgrounds often face even greater hurdles in education and employment. Official figures show that boys eligible for free school meals have particularly low attainment levels at GCSE.

For example, in 2023, only 34% of White British FSM-eligible boys achieved grade 4 or above in both English and maths. Similar low attainment was seen for FSM-eligible mixed White and Black Caribbean boys and Caribbean boys. While girls from these backgrounds also face challenges, the gender gap often persists within these groups. Any effective strategy to support young men must therefore adopt an intersectional approach, recognising and addressing these multiple layers of disadvantage to ensure that support reaches those who need it most.

Looking Ahead: A Call for Comprehensive Action

The information paints a clear picture: a considerable segment of male youths within the United Kingdom experience difficulties. The disparities in educational attainment, the crisis concerning male psychological well-being, and the challenges involved in progressing towards a stable maturity demand urgent and comprehensive action. This is not about pitting genders against each other but about ensuring that all young people, irrespective of gender, are afforded the chance to realise their utmost capabilities.

Suggested initiatives include a dedicated strategy for men's education, learning from efforts to get more women into STEM to encourage men into teaching and care roles, and greater focus on gender disparities in school inspections and university access plans. Addressing these issues requires a societal commitment to understanding the unique pressures young men face, challenging harmful stereotypes, providing tailored support systems, and creating educational and economic opportunities that allow them to thrive. The future well-being of these young men, and indeed society as a whole, depends on it.