Solar System Planetary Defence

Cosmic Sentinels: Charting Asteroids, Unveiling Solar System Secrets, and Protecting Earth

Nasa keeps watchful eyes on the heavens. According to a recent space agency report, a newly detected asteroid has a slight chance of striking the Moon. While unlikely, such an event offers invaluable opportunities to understand Earth's history and prepare for potential future impacts. The study of asteroids provides a window into the very beginnings of our solar system. These celestial wanderers hold clues about planetary formation and the origins of life itself. Constant vigilance and ongoing research are crucial components of planetary defence. International collaboration ensures the most comprehensive approach to monitoring these ancient space rocks. This coordinated effort helps refine our understanding of potential threats and develop mitigation strategies.

Daily Arrivals and Lingering Threats

Space is far from empty. Nasa estimates that, each year, a celestial rock roughly car-sized enters Earth’s vicinity. Our planet possesses a robust atmospheric shield. This protective layer typically causes incoming asteroids to disintegrate harmlessly. Observers on the ground often witness these events as spectacular meteor displays or fireballs streaking across the night sky. These frequent, smaller events pose little danger. However, significantly larger asteroids represent a more serious concern for planetary safety. Their potential for destruction warrants continuous monitoring and research efforts by space agencies globally. Understanding the frequency and nature of these smaller impacts helps calibrate models for larger threats.

The Scale of Asteroid Risks

Catastrophic impacts remain exceedingly rare events. Planetary scientist Michael Küppers, from the European Space Agency (ESA), puts this into perspective. He explains that asteroids comparable in size to the one linked with the dinosaur extinction, roughly 10 kilometres wide, strike Earth only over vast geological timescales. Nevertheless, smaller asteroids, though less devastating, still present tangible risks. An impact from a multi-metre object could cause significant regional damage. Therefore, ongoing detection and characterisation programmes are essential. These efforts aim to identify potentially hazardous objects long before they pose an imminent threat, allowing time for analysis and potential intervention. The cumulative effect of smaller impacts over millennia also shapes planetary surfaces.

Image Credit - Freepik

Focus on 2024 YR4

Astronomers first sighted Asteroid 2024 YR4 in December 2024, sparking global interest. Initial observations by the Asteroid Terrestrial-impact Last Alert System (ATLAS) telescope in Chile provided preliminary size estimates. These placed the asteroid's diameter between 40 and 90 metres, taller than a twelve-story building. The ESA initially calculated a small but non-negligible Earth impact probability for 22 December 2032. Subsequent observations refined these calculations. As of February 2025, extensive tracking ruled out a significant Earth impact risk, downgrading the probability to 0.001% and removing it from ESA's risk list. The International Asteroid Warning Network (IAWN) concluded its related activities for this object regarding Earth impact.

YR4's Lingering Lunar Question

While the Earth impact risk for 2024 YR4 diminished significantly, continued observations raised a slight possibility of a lunar collision. Updated analyses incorporating data from Nasa's James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) adjusted the estimated size of 2024 YR4 to between 53 and 67 metres (174 to 220 feet). These infrared observations provided a more precise measurement than earlier visible light estimates. As of early April 2025, Nasa's Center for Near Earth Object Studies calculated a 3.8% chance of 2024 YR4 impacting the Moon on 22 December 2032. This represented an increase from earlier estimates but still indicated a 96.2% chance the asteroid will safely miss the Moon. Astronomers emphasise such a lunar impact, though scientifically interesting, would not alter the orbit of the Moon.

Windows into the Past

Observed asteroids offer more than just potential hazard assessment. Alan Fitzsimmons, an astronomer at Queen's University Belfast involved in Nasa's Near-Earth Object (NEO) programme, explains their scientific value. These celestial remnants are pieces that survived the birth of our solar system. They represent remnants of the larger celestial bodies present billions of years ago. Studying their chemical composition provides unique insights. Scientists gain glimpses into the physical and chemical conditions prevailing at the solar system's birth, approximately 4.6 billion years prior. Each asteroid acts as a time capsule, preserving primordial material largely unchanged since its formation, unlike the heavily processed materials found on planets.

Minor Planets: A Diverse Population

Frequently termed minor planetary bodies, these ancient celestial remnants exhibit remarkable diversity. Asteroids vary considerably in shape, size, and rotation. Some travel through space alone, while others exist as binary pairs, where two asteroids orbit each other. Remarkably, some larger asteroids even possess their own moons. Nasa's Jet Propulsion Laboratory currently documents over 1.4 million asteroids within our solar system. The vast majority reside in the main asteroid belt, a zone situated between the orbits of Mars and Jupiter. Countless smaller, undiscovered asteroids likely populate this region as well. Jupiter's immense gravitational influence acts as a shepherd, generally confining these bodies within the belt.

Image Credit - Freepik

Straying from the Belt

Despite Jupiter's gravitational containment, the main asteroid belt is not a perfectly closed system. Occasionally, gravitational interactions disrupt the orbits of asteroids within the belt. A nudge from another asteroid or a gravitational tug from Jupiter itself can send an asteroid careening onto a new path. Some of these diverted objects find themselves on trajectories that cross the orbits of the inner planets, including Earth. These become Near-Earth Objects (NEOs), the focus of planetary defence efforts. Identifying and tracking these errant asteroids presents the first crucial challenge in mitigating potential impact risks. Their unpredictable paths require constant monitoring and sophisticated orbital calculations.

The Challenge of Detection

Locating potentially hazardous asteroids requires sophisticated techniques and constant vigilance. Kelly Fast, formerly Nasa's acting planetary defense chief, explains the difficulty. Through telescopes, asteroids appear merely as moving points of light against the backdrop of stationary stars. Their brightness, a key factor in detection, depends on several variables. An asteroid's size influences how much sunlight it reflects. Its surface composition and colour (albedo) also play a significant role. Darker asteroids reflect less light, making them harder to spot than brighter ones of equivalent size. This explains why initial size estimates for objects like 2024 YR4 often cover a wide range, such as 40 to 90 metres, until more data is gathered.

Refining the View with Infrared

Gathering more extensive information allows scientists to refine initial asteroid estimations. Visible light observations provide a starting point, but other methods offer greater precision. Infrared readings prove particularly valuable. Space telescopes like the James Webb ST possess powerful infrared capabilities. By measuring the heat radiated by an asteroid, astronomers can calculate its size more accurately, largely independent of its surface reflectivity. Nasa and ESA teams planned and utilised JWST observations for 2024 YR4. This data significantly narrowed the size estimate to 53-67 metres, improving the accuracy of orbital predictions and impact risk assessments, including the potential lunar collision.

A Spectrum of Compositions

The asteroid population showcases remarkable diversity not just in size and orbit, but also in composition. Kelly Fast notes this heterogeneity. An asteroid's origin significantly influences what it is made of. Broadly, scientists classify asteroids into three main types based on their spectral characteristics, which reveal their composition. The most common are carbonaceous (C-type) asteroids. These dark objects, resembling coal, contain significant amounts of carbon and make up over three-quarters of known asteroids. Understanding these compositional differences is vital. It informs scientific studies about solar system formation and is crucial for assessing potential impact threats and planning mitigation strategies.

Stony and Metallic Asteroids

Beyond the dominant C-type asteroids, two other major groups exist. Silicaceous (S-type) asteroids constitute the next largest category. These asteroids feature a combination of silicate (stony) materials and metals, primarily nickel and iron. The third main group comprises metallic (M-type) asteroids. These are composed largely of nickel and iron, similar to the cores of planets like Earth. While these three types (C, S, M) represent the majority, other rarer asteroid classifications exist, reflecting the complex history and varied origins of these small solar system bodies. Each type offers unique scientific insights and presents different considerations for planetary defence scenarios.

Psyche 16: A Metallic Giant

One particularly intriguing object is Psyche 16. This large, metal-rich asteroid resides within the main asteroid belt between Jupiter and Mars. Its shape is irregular, often described as roughly potato-like. Psyche 16 has captured intense scientific interest due to its unusual composition. Scientists estimate it could consist of up to 95% iron and nickel, materials predominantly found in the cores of terrestrial planets. Studying Psyche 16 promises valuable information about planet formation, particularly the processes that lead to core differentiation. It may represent an exposed planetary core from a protoplanet destroyed early in the solar system's history.

Journey to a Metal World

The unique nature of Psyche 16 prompted Nasa to develop a dedicated mission. The Nasa Psyche spacecraft launched successfully and is currently en route to its target. The mission aims for an orbital rendezvous with Psyche 16 in August 2029. Once in orbit, the spacecraft will spend years studying the asteroid in detail. Its instruments will map the surface, determine its precise composition, measure its magnetic field, and probe its internal structure. This investigation seeks to answer fundamental questions about how planets form and evolve. Psyche offers a chance to explore a type of world – an exposed metal core – never before visited by a spacecraft.

Untold Riches in Space?

Metal-rich asteroids like Psyche 16 hold not only scientific value but also potential economic significance. Estimates suggest the metals contained within Psyche 16 alone could be worth staggering sums, perhaps around $10 quadrillion based on current terrestrial market values. This highlights the immense resource potential residing in asteroids. Looking towards the future, asteroid mining might transition from science fiction to reality. Extracting valuable resources from space could become necessary, potentially profitable, and technologically feasible as Earth's terrestrial resources dwindle and space exploration technology advances. However, significant logistical and economic hurdles remain before asteroid mining becomes commonplace.

Image Credit - Freepik

Composition and Planetary Defence

Understanding asteroid composition directly informs planetary defence strategies. The type of material an asteroid is made of significantly affects the potential devastation of an impact. Dense, iron-rich bodies like M-type asteroids possess greater mass for their size compared to less dense carbonaceous C-types. Upon impact, this greater mass translates into increased kinetic energy delivery, causing significantly more damage. Furthermore, an asteroid's internal structure – whether it is a solid monolithic body or a loosely bound aggregate of fragments (a "rubble pile") – also influences how it interacts with Earth's atmosphere and the nature of the resulting impact event.

Lessons from the Moon

The Moon's surface serves as a stark reminder of asteroid impacts throughout solar system history. Unlike Earth, the Moon lacks a substantial protective atmosphere. Consequently, its surface bears the unmitigated scars of countless asteroid strikes over billions of years, ranging from microscopic pits to vast basins. Studying these lunar craters provides invaluable data on the frequency and scale of impacts in Earth's neighbourhood. While experts deemed an Earth impact from 2024 YR4 highly improbable after extensive observation, the calculated, albeit small, possibility of a lunar collision (updated to 3.8% in April 2025) underscores the dynamic nature of objects in near-Earth space and the utility of lunar impact studies.

Rubble Piles vs. Solid Rocks

An asteroid's internal structure is a critical factor in assessing its potential hazard. Alan Fitzsimmons explains that understanding whether an asteroid is a solid piece of rock or a collection of loosely bound fragments – a "rubble pile" – helps predict its behaviour upon entering Earth's atmosphere. Many asteroids smaller than about 10 kilometres across fall into these categories: fractured solid bodies or gravitational aggregates. Fitzsimmons cautions against assuming a rubble pile structure makes an asteroid less dangerous. Asteroids typically enter the atmosphere at extremely high velocities, around 17 kilometres per second. This immense speed leaves only seconds for atmospheric transit before surface impact or air burst.

The Danger of Air Bursts

Even without directly striking the ground, asteroids can inflict significant damage. Earth's atmosphere offers protection, but it is not absolute. An asteroid the size of 2024 YR4 (estimated 53-67 metres) might detonate several kilometres above the surface. While such an event lacks ground penetration, the resulting explosion unleashes a powerful shockwave. Fitzsimmons notes this aerial blast can be comparable in destructive force to a direct surface impact, devastating a wide area below. The configuration of 2024 YR4 – solid rock or rubble pile – remains unknown, but its potential for destruction via an air burst is a serious consideration, mirroring past events.

The Chelyabinsk Precedent

The potential destructive power of an air burst was vividly demonstrated in 2013 over Chelyabinsk, Russia. An asteroid estimated to be only about 20 metres wide detonated at an altitude of roughly 22.5 to 30 kilometres. The explosion radiated light momentarily outshining the Sun itself. Its powerful shockwave arrived later, travelling slower than light, and caused widespread damage. Over 7,200 buildings across six cities suffered damage, primarily shattered windows. Approximately 1,500 people sustained injuries, mostly from flying glass when they went to windows after seeing the initial flash. Michael Küppers considers this size threshold – around 20 metres – significant regarding potential impacts on populated areas.

A Wake-Up Call and Global Cooperation

The Chelyabinsk event served as a stark cosmic wake-up call. Coincidentally, the meteor exploded on the very day a UN committee was meeting in Vienna to discuss defence strategies against space rock impacts. This dramatic confluence spurred greater international action. Nasa helped establish the IAWN. IAWN, coordinated by Nasa, fosters collaboration among global space agencies and astronomical institutions. It acts as a clearing house for observations, recommends notification criteria, and assists governments in analysing impact consequences and planning responses, linking observers worldwide through a dedicated advisory committee.

Image Credit - Freepik

Early Asteroid Encounters

Humanity's efforts to scrutinise space rocks began decades ago. The Galileo spacecraft, primarily focused on Jupiter, examined two main-belt asteroids, Gaspra and Ida, during its journey in the early ‘90s. These flybys provided the first close-up images of asteroids. Later, in the year 2000, Nasa's Near-Earth Asteroid Rendezvous (NEAR) Shoemaker mission achieved another milestone. It became the first artificial satellite to successfully orbit an asteroid, the S-type object Eros. The mission culminated in an unprecedented landing on Eros's surface the following year, gathering valuable data even after touchdown. These pioneering missions laid the groundwork for subsequent, more ambitious explorations.

Bringing Samples Home

Japan's space agency, JAXA, achieved remarkable success with its Hayabusa missions. The first Hayabusa spacecraft visited asteroid Itokawa, returning minuscule samples in 2010 despite technical difficulties. Its successor, Hayabusa2, targeted 162173 Ryugu, a C-type (carbonaceous) asteroid. The spacecraft studied Ryugu extensively during 2018–2019. It successfully deployed landers and collected surface samples before departing. The sample return capsule landed safely in Australia in December 2020, providing scientists with pristine material from a carbon-rich asteroid, complementing samples from other asteroid types and offering insights into the distribution of organic materials in the early solar system.

OSIRIS-REx and Bennu's Secrets

Nasa's OSIRIS-REx mission targeted another carbonaceous near-Earth asteroid, Bennu. The spacecraft arrived at Bennu in 2018, mapped its surface in detail, and collected a substantial sample in 2020. The sample capsule successfully returned to Earth in September 2023. Subsequent analysis of the Bennu samples yielded groundbreaking discoveries. Published in early 2025, studies revealed the presence of crucial molecules for life, including 14 out of the 20 amino acids Earth life uses for proteins, and all five nucleobases used in DNA and RNA. High abundances of ammonia and evidence of ancient brines were also found.

Life's Building Blocks from Space

The discovery of complex organic molecules and evidence of past water activity in the Bennu samples strongly supports theories about the origin of life on Earth. These findings suggest that asteroids like Bennu could have delivered essential precursor ingredients – water and organic compounds – to the early Earth billions of years ago. While not evidence of life itself on Bennu, the presence of these building blocks in a pristine extraterrestrial sample indicates the conditions necessary for life's emergence were widespread in the early solar system. Scientists noted finding both left- and right-handed versions of amino acids, unlike life on Earth which exclusively uses left-handed forms, posing further questions about life's origins.

OSIRIS-APEX: A New Target

Following its successful sample return from Bennu, the OSIRIS-REx spacecraft received a mission extension and a new name: OSIRIS-APEX (Apophis Explorer). Its next target is asteroid 99942 Apophis. This S-type (stony) asteroid gained notoriety after its discovery in 2004 due to initial calculations suggesting a potential Earth impact risk in 2029. Further observations ruled out this possibility for the foreseeable future. However, Apophis will make an exceptionally close approach to Earth on 13 April 2029, passing closer than geostationary satellites. This rare event offers a unique opportunity to study the effects of planetary tidal forces on an asteroid.

Studying Tidal Effects on Apophis

The OSIRIS-APEX mission aims to rendezvous with Apophis shortly after its 2029 Earth flyby. The spacecraft will then orbit the asteroid for approximately 18 months. During this time, it will study any physical changes induced by Earth's gravitational pull during the close encounter. Scientists expect potential alterations to Apophis's orbit, its rotation speed, and possibly surface features due to quakes or landslides. OSIRIS-APEX will map the stony asteroid in high resolution, analyse its composition using its instrument suite (including the Canadian OLA laser altimeter), and even perform a thruster manoeuvre close to the surface to expose and study subsurface material, providing valuable data on S-type asteroids and planetary defence.

DART: Deflecting an Asteroid

Planetary defence research includes testing mitigation techniques. Nasa's DART mission, launched in 2021, provided the first full-scale demonstration of kinetic impact technology. The mission targeted Dimorphos, the small moonlet orbiting the larger asteroid Didymos – a safe, non-threatening binary system chosen specifically for this test. In September 2022, the DART spacecraft deliberately collided with Dimorphos at high speed, roughly 11 million kilometres from Earth. The goal was to measure how effectively the impact altered Dimorphos's orbit around Didymos through momentum transfer.

DART's Resounding Success

Observations following the DART impact confirmed the mission's success beyond expectations. Analysis showed the collision significantly shortened Dimorphos's orbital period around Didymos by 32 minutes (with a +/- 2 minute uncertainty). This far exceeded the mission's minimum success benchmark of a 73-second change. The deflection resulted not just from the spacecraft's momentum but, significantly, from the recoil generated by the vast amount of rock and dust (ejecta) blasted from the asteroid's surface by the impact. Further studies revealed the impact also dramatically reshaped Dimorphos, changing it from a relatively symmetrical shape to a more elongated one, confirming that kinetic impact is a viable asteroid deflection technique.

Synergy Between Science and Defence

The recent missions highlight the close relationship between pure scientific exploration and applied planetary defence. Does the success of DART signal a shift towards defence-oriented missions? Kelly Fast, during discussions about Nasa's structure, emphasised the synergy between the two fields. Nasa's Planetary Defense Coordination Office (PDCO) operates within the agency's Planetary Science Division. This integration ensures that scientific understanding of asteroids – their origins, composition, structure, and behaviour – directly informs defence strategies. Studying these remnants from the solar system's formation enhances our knowledge of cosmic history while simultaneously improving our ability to predict, assess, and potentially mitigate impact threats, safeguarding our planet.