Cryotherapy: The Cold Hard Truth

The Lethal Chill: Inside the Booming and Risky World of Cryotherapy

In a city known for its beauty and wellness culture, a tragic incident in Paris this spring cast a harsh light on the booming cryotherapy industry. Two women lost their lives inside a cryotherapy facility at a high-end gym, prompting urgent questions about the safety and efficacy of a treatment celebrated by athletes and wellness gurus alike. This event has forced a closer look at a rapidly growing market, where the distinction between therapeutic treatment and cosmetic indulgence becomes increasingly blurred.

Emergency services descended on the On Air fitness center, which is situated on Boulevard Voltaire within the 11th district of Paris, on a mild April evening. The modern, four-storey facility, positioned between the historic Bastille and the Père Lachaise burial ground, became the scene of a devastating accident. The incident has since sparked a vigorous discussion about the regulation and scientific backing of whole-body cryotherapy (WBC), a practice that subjects the body to temperatures far below natural extremes.

A Scene of Tragedy

Inside the state-of-the-art gym, first responders made a grim discovery. One was a 29-year-old staff member, Alison Portales, while the other was a 34-year-old customer who had completed the Paris marathon just one day prior. The marathon participant was utilizing the establishment’s WBC pod for recuperation purposes following her demanding athletic effort. Supporters of the method assert that the profoundly cold environment inside the pod diminishes muscle inflammation. The chamber, however, is suspected to have suffered a catastrophic nitrogen leak following recent repairs.

This leak would have dangerously lowered the concentration of breathable oxygen within the space, leading to asphyxiation. Upon their discovery, three gym employees attempted to perform resuscitation, as authorities evacuated roughly 150 patrons from the premises. Ms. Portales was declared deceased later that evening. The runner was transported to a hospital and put on life-support but was pronounced brain dead forty-eight hours later. The employees who made the revival effort were also hospitalized for observation.

The Allure of Extreme Cold

Cryotherapy pods have experienced a dramatic rise in popularity, extending far beyond the realm of professional sports. Enthusiasts now seek cosmetic enhancements, such as revitalized skin, assistance with weight reduction, and even an enhanced libido. The global cryotherapy market is valued in the hundreds of millions of pounds and is projected to grow significantly, demonstrating its expanding appeal. For many, weekly sessions have become a routine part of their wellness regimen.

The appeal lies in the promise of a quick fix. Proponents claim that just a few minutes in a chamber cooled to below -100°C can offer a host of benefits. These range from reduced inflammation and faster muscle repair to boosted immunity and improved circulation. The deep-seated belief in the therapeutic qualities of frigid water has roots reaching back to at least the ancient Greeks; "cryo" translates to cold while "therapeia" means cure.

A Growing Market in the UK

The United Kingdom has not been immune to this trend. The UK cryotherapy market is a multi-million pound industry with strong projected growth through 2030. From just one commercial practice over a decade ago, dozens of venues are now available through booking websites. The industry’s growth in Europe is significant, with the UK, Germany, and France leading the charge.

This expansion is fuelled by an increasing number of cryotherapy centres and the popularity of non-invasive treatments in aesthetics and pain management. In cities like Paris and London, where pharmacies and beauty salons are on every corner, cryotherapy is now a trendy offering at high-end spas. The distinction between a beauty parlor and a health facility can be ambiguous, creating a fertile ground for such wellness crazes.

Image Credit - Freepik

Questions of Safety and Regulation

Despite its growing popularity, the incident in Paris highlights the potential dangers. Fatalities are rare, but the event underscores the risks associated with nitrogen-cooled chambers. Nitrogen, a colourless and odourless gas, can displace oxygen in enclosed spaces, leading to a risk of asphyxiation if not properly ventilated. This has prompted calls for stricter safety protocols and better staff training.

Some industry veterans argue that accidents are often the result of inferior equipment. Many believe that a built-in oxygen monitor is essential for safety, recalling instances where chambers have been sold without one. This highlights the inconsistencies in equipment standards across the industry. The lack of standardized regulation means that the quality and safety of cryotherapy chambers can vary dramatically from one provider to another.

The Science: A Chilly Reception

While anecdotes and celebrity endorsements abound, the scientific evidence supporting many of cryotherapy’s claims remains thin. Major public health bodies have consistently declined to approve its use for medical conditions, citing a lack of evidence. Official reviews have found very little proof of its safety or effectiveness in treating the myriad conditions for which it is promoted.

A landmark systematic review of scientific literature—a Cochrane Review—on the effectiveness of cryotherapy for addressing muscle pain reached a critical conclusion. This type of review, representing the highest standard in evidence-based medical practice, determined the available data was not strong enough to endorse using full-body cryotherapy to treat muscle soreness. This was the very issue that first propelled cryotherapy into the mainstream and brought the marathon runner to visit the On Air facility in Paris.

Image Credit - Freepik

A Placebo Effect?

Regarding other supposed benefits, the scientific assessment is equally critical. The proof to back up any of those assertions is genuinely weak. The most extensive body of research exists in the sports recovery domain, and even that is quite restricted. So why do a multitude of sports teams passionately support its effectiveness?

One theory is that no organization wants to seem as if it is lagging behind its competitors. There is also some data suggesting a perceptual or placebo advantage, where individuals believe the treatment is benefiting them, which in turn can have a positive psychological effect. This powerful psychological component cannot be dismissed, but it does not equate to a physiological cure.

The Celebrity Endorsement Engine

The cryotherapy phenomenon has been significantly fuelled by high-profile endorsements. Footballer Cristiano Ronaldo reportedly had a machine installed in his home. Other famous names like Jennifer Aniston, Daniel Craig, Jessica Alba, and Gigi Hadid have all publicly praised its benefits. This celebrity halo effect has undoubtedly contributed to its mainstream acceptance and the booming market.

From NBA stars like LeBron James to Hollywood actors like Will Smith, the list of proponents is long and influential. They cite benefits ranging from faster recovery and skin toning to mood enhancement. While these personal testimonials are compelling, they often overshadow the lack of rigorous scientific validation for the wide-ranging assertions promoted by the field.

Image Credit - Freepik

Exploring the Risks

Beyond the rare but catastrophic risk of nitrogen leaks, other potential side effects exist. Exposure to such extreme cold can cause frostbite, burns, rashes, swelling, and skin discolouration. More serious reported side effects include memory loss, cerebral bleeding, and abdominal aortic dissection. People with certain pre-existing conditions, such as heart, respiratory, or vascular issues, are at a heightened risk.

The temperatures involved in WBC greatly surpass the natural limits our planet offers. While proponents argue that the air is dry, mitigating some of the cold’s harshness, the potential for harm remains. Consent forms at clinics list contraindications, with heart conditions being a primary concern due to the massive impact on blood flow. The industry’s rapid, largely unregulated growth means consumers may not always be fully aware of these dangers.

Alternative Cold Therapies

The fascination with extreme temperatures is not limited to cryotherapy chambers. The popularity of ice-cold baths and the cold water submersion, championed by motivational figures, reflects a broader trend. These practices, often grouped under "cold water therapy," are also largely unregulated and carry their own risks, including hypothermia and cardiac events.

Despite the dangers, thousands upon thousands of individuals champion the invigorating effects of winter swimming and cold plunges. Proponents of these methods claim they can boost the immune system, diminish muscle pain, and improve mental health. However, recent reviews suggest that while there may be some benefits, the scientific evidence is often of low quality and requires further investigation.

The Rise of Contrast Therapy

Another popular treatment is "contrast therapy," which involves alternating between extreme heat and cold. A session might expose the body to temperatures shifting from an 80°C sauna to a -196°C cryo-chamber in minutes. This rapid shift is believed to create a pumping action in the blood vessels, enhancing circulation, reducing inflammation, and speeding up recovery.

This therapy is gaining traction in gyms and spas across the UK. However, like other extreme temperature treatments, it is not without risk. It can be dangerous for individuals with certain health conditions, and scalding from water that is too hot is a possible hazard. Experts advise consulting a healthcare provider before embarking on such treatments, particularly for those with pre-existing health issues.

The Cosmetic Frontier

While cryotherapy’s roots are in athletic recovery, its future may lie in cosmetics. Salons are increasingly offering "body sculpting" and "slimming" treatments using localised cryotherapy. The claim is that frigid conditions help burn calories through a mechanism called thermogenesis. This is now among the most lucrative assertions promoted by the industry.

Scientific analysis suggests that although it might be feasible to achieve significant calorie expenditure with repeated WBC sessions, the data supporting this weight-reduction effect is tentative at best. In his judgment, WBC should not be promoted as a reliable method for long-term weight management. Despite this, the allure of a quick and easy path to a slimmer figure continues to draw in customers.

Image Credit - Freepik

The Technology Behind the Chill

Cryotherapy chambers are not all created equal. The two main types are nitrogen-cooled and electric. Nitrogen chambers can cool down rapidly but come with the inherent risks of handling and storing liquid nitrogen, including the danger of asphyxiation if ventilation is inadequate. They also have ongoing operational costs for nitrogen supplies.

Electric chambers eliminate the need for nitrogen, using chilled, breathable air instead. This removes the risk of suffocation and allows for full-body exposure, including the head, which proponents say enhances the physiological response. While electric models have a higher initial cost, they are often seen as a safer and more user-friendly alternative in the long run.

A System in Need of Oversight

The Paris tragedy has starkly illustrated the potential consequences when things go wrong in an unregulated industry. The lack of universal safety standards, staff training requirements, and equipment certification leaves consumers vulnerable. Across the United Kingdom and much of Europe, the cryotherapy market operates in a grey area, without the stringent oversight applied to medical procedures.

This regulatory gap allows for a wide variation in the quality of services offered. A review was apparently submitted by an unhappy client a month before the fatal nitrogen incident at the On Air gym, complaining about the lack of protective gear for their extremities and calling the service "very amateur." This highlights how easily safety protocols can be overlooked in the absence of mandatory standards.

The Path Forward

But do people truly follow health warnings when an activity makes them feel uplifted? The endorphin rush and feelings of exhilaration reported by many cryotherapy users are powerful motivators. The subjective experience often outweighs the warnings from the scientific community. The catastrophe in Paris might prompt some reflection, but the burgeoning wellness industry shows no signs of slowing down.

For consumers, the key is to make informed choices. This means understanding the limited scientific evidence, being aware of the possible hazards, and choosing reputable providers with robust safety measures. For the industry, the incident should serve as a wake-up call to prioritize safety over profit and to work towards establishing clear and enforceable regulations. The future of cryotherapy may depend on its ability to prove it is not just cool, but also safe.