Cat Cafes and Feline Welfare Debate

Are Feline-Themed Coffee Houses, Deemed Superior to Confined Spaces by Some, Now a Subject of Intense Debate?

A growing number of establishments provide patrons with opportunities for feline interaction while they enjoy their coffee. Certain venues consider their primary role as sanctuaries rather than commercial enterprises. What motivates animal welfare organizations to advocate for their closure?

The Rise of Feline Cafes and Public Appeal

In Norwich, on a sunlit Wednesday afternoon, around three o'clock, the Dereham Road coffee house experiences a distinct lull typical of mid-week, mid-day. Nearly all inhabitants are dozing, at least until the familiar sound of a Dreamies container signals treat time. The Cat House, inaugurated almost two full years prior, stands as the municipality's pioneering feline coffee spot. For an admission fee of £10, visitors can engage with cats for sixty minutes from Wednesday through Sunday; ninety minutes of interaction costs £13, accompanied by drinks and light fare. Several individuals are present, along with twenty felines who reside in the generously sized, repurposed structure.

A Glimpse Inside a Norwich Establishment

The animals recline on elevated cat perches, conceal themselves within cartons and passages, and navigate around the legs of tables. Guests move with deference in the animals' vicinity, anticipating a moment of their regard. The subdued conversations, the murmur of a water feature, and televised nature documentaries lend The Cat House an atmosphere more akin to a reading room than a typical café. No indication exists of the contentious discussion surrounding its very right to operate.

Welfare Charities Sound the Alarm on Rapid Growth

A couple of months earlier, both the RSPCA and the organization Cats Protection jointly advocated for the gradual elimination of feline coffee houses. They stated that achieving guaranteed well-being for the animals in such settings was "exceedingly difficult." Previously a unique phenomenon, this business model has become fairly widespread within the United Kingdom, extending beyond large metropolitan areas. Information obtained through a freedom of information inquiry reveals thirty-two licensed feline coffee houses operating throughout England, with none in Wales.

Given that 44 percent of these permits were issued in the preceding fiscal year, their numbers appear poised for further expansion. Since licensing is not uniformly mandated across all regions, the charitable bodies also harbor suspicions that additional venues function without any official scrutiny. This abrupt proliferation prompted the two groups to adopt a unified position, urging local governing bodies to refuse new license requests and to refrain from renewing those already in effect.

Stress and Confinement: Key Concerns for Felines

Alice Potter, a senior scientific officer and an expert on feline welfare for the RSPCA, explains that inadequate regulation or the potential for unethical business practices do not solely drive her organization’s stance. A central element of their apprehension involves the possible stress induced by the restricted living conditions, made worse by the continual presence of other felines and human patrons. While Potter concedes that operational methods "differ substantially" from one place to another, she maintains that these inherent obstacles cannot be avoided. She communicated that felines are simply unsuited to a coffee house existence, noting the inherent limitations on available territory and autonomy.

Image Credit - Freepik

Cafe Owners Express Dismay at Generalisations

For the operators of feline coffee houses, however, this movement lacks essential subtlety and appeared to materialize quite unexpectedly. Tasmin Hirst, a joint proprietor of North Tyneside's Bad Cat Cafe and Rescue in Wallsend, expressed her genuine astonishment. She initiated a petition on Change.org, appealing to Cats Protection and the RSPCA to make a clear differentiation between profit-oriented commercial feline coffee houses and those functioning chiefly as rescue centers. This petition has now garnered close to nineteen thousand endorsements from concerned individuals.

A Rescue-Focused Alternative Model

Her particular enterprise maintains a deliberately modest scale, accommodating a maximum of eight felines simultaneously, with the primary goal of securing lasting residences for them. At the time of our discussion, the establishment housed only six cats, two having found new families the day before. Hirst described her venue as hardly a coffee house at all, stating it operates more like a refuge, where they offer sustenance and refreshments to generate income for the animals' care. She elaborated that the name of the place is intentionally lighthearted, a witty approach to temper visitor expectations if the felines prove reserved or shy.

A Lifeline for Unwanted Cats?

The majority of felines arriving at her establishment originate from nearby shelters operating at full capacity, or from individuals compelled to surrender their companion animals. Hirst mentioned that her coffee house can usually accommodate bonded animal companions or small feline families, which larger shelters might otherwise be forced to separate. She remarked, with a sense of irony, that they frequently accept felines that Cats Protection and the RSPCA have declined to take. Animals that dislike the coffee house setting or are not a good fit receive placement in local foster care situations.

Facilitating Adoptions in a Relaxed Setting

Hirst firmly believes, however, that residing in the coffee house represents a significant improvement over being kept in a kennel. For individuals looking to adopt, it also offers a more tranquil method of encountering potential new animal family members. She explained that they become so familiar with the animals that they can effectively match them with appropriate families. They provide reassurance by promising to accept the feline back if any issues arise following an adoption. She calculates that felines typically stay at the coffee house for an average of two months, and in its two and a half years of operation, the Bad Cat Cafe has successfully placed 150 felines in new adoptive situations.

Concerns Over Licensing and Public Perception

Hirst voices unease regarding more commercially focused ventures and the current licensing system. She reported that they obtain the same kind of permit formerly issued to pet retail outlets, even though the concept is entirely different, adding that she does not oppose increased oversight or site visits. Nevertheless, she is apprehensive that the reproval from Cats Protection and the RSPCA, which she feels "unjustly categorizes all cat cafes together," will adversely impact her own establishment. A short while before their conversation, someone had scratched the coffee house’s window with a key. Hirst speculated that it might have been youngsters, as it was during school holidays, but equally, it could have been an individual who had absorbed negative information about feline coffee houses. She expressed concern about the public's continued trust in these organisations, especially among older generations, and how this might tarnish the community's view of their work.

Image Credit - Freepik

The Global Origins and Rise of Cat Cafes

It is possible that some individuals are only now becoming acquainted with the feline coffee house model. The BBC indicates that the very first such establishment commenced operations in 1998 in Taipei, Taiwan, housing merely five rescued street felines. When this notion migrated to Japan in the early part of the 2000s, it gained immense traction among young urban professionals whose compact living spaces and stringent rental agreements precluded pet ownership. Vice documented the opening of seventy-nine feline coffee houses across Japan between 2005 and 2010. Several years after that, a temporary feline coffee house appeared in New York, a promotional endeavor by the Purina One pet food company. Subsequently, in 2015, the term "cat cafe" found its way into the online Oxford Dictionary.

Social Media Influence and Exotic Appeal

Their progressive diffusion across the United States, the United Kingdom, the Middle East, and Europe ran parallel to the ascent of social media. This created a fresh emphasis on originality, visual appeal, and "experiences" suitable for Instagram sharing. Feline coffee houses frequently attract patrons by featuring distinctive breeds, aesthetically pleasing environments, and the allure of a prime photo opportunity. Elizabeth Mullineaux, president of the British Veterinary Association, an organization that advocates for regulation, stated that while the vast majority of owners, employees, and visitors at feline coffee houses undoubtedly hold affection for the animals, the unfortunate truth is that these environments might prioritize human entertainment over the felines' well-being.

Expert Views on Feline Social Needs

Lucy Hoile, a specialist in feline behavior, concurs that these venues seldom provide "a perfect setting" for felines and their intricate social requirements. The common idea of them as solitary, unsociable creatures is not entirely correct; they are capable of forming significant attachments and social units. However, Hoile explained that, ideally, they should possess the autonomy to avoid one another if they so choose, an opportunity she feels the structure of a feline coffee house generally fails to provide its animal inhabitants.

The Ideal vs. Reality: Subtle Signs of Stress

The most favorable arrangement, Hoile posits, would involve a facility centered around a "secure, deeply bonded collective of felines who genuinely appreciate each other." However, this is not consistent with her experiences during visits to a small number of such establishments as a patron. She observed that many felines appear to be merely enduring the situation. While they might not be lashing out at people or engaging in major altercations, numerous subtle indicators of anxiety are apparent, such as retreating or feigning sleep.

Hoile cautions that this ongoing tension can render them more prone to sickness and contribute to their general unhappiness, yet these cues are not always readily apparent, even to individuals with considerable experience with felines. She expresses empathy for those coffee house proprietors whose main motivation is to aid and honor felines, acknowledging the immense difficulty in curating the ideal mix of felines and configuring the environment for a positive outcome.

Image Credit - Freepik

A Resident Feline Family in Norwich

Sarah Price, the proprietor and operator of The Cat House in Norwich, asserts she has achieved this balance with her collective of twenty resident felines. Observing them arrayed together for treats, one might find it difficult to accept they all belong to the same animal group. Among them is Romeo, a vast blue-grey Maine Coon with a leonine visage, whose ears practically reach a person's knees. Khamoon, the Sphynx without fur, possesses intense grey-blue irises and a hide reminiscent of chamois leather. Augustus Le-Blanc, more commonly Gus, a ginger-cream Ragdoll, is characterized as "amiable but not overly bright." None of these twenty animals are designated for adoption.

Motivation Beyond Profit: A Love for Cats

Price cheerfully dismisses the notion that this classifies The Cat House as a predominantly for-profit enterprise. Over a cup of tea from a mug declaring "BEST CAT MOM EVER," she insisted that financial considerations are secondary and that her actions are driven by her profound affection for felines. The conversation occurred on the outdoor "catio," under the watchful eye of Lily the Lykoi (nicknamed the "werewolf cat" due to a somewhat sparse coat, though still possessing a certain appeal), perched on the uppermost level of a nearby feline climbing structure, observing the surroundings.

Curating a Harmonious Feline Community

Although Price frequently uses The Cat House’s online presence to showcase felines in need of new families, she stated she would "absolutely not contemplate" facilitating adoptions directly from the coffee house itself. The current ensemble of felines, she explained, was meticulously put together over a period, primarily as young kittens, whom Price believes adapt more readily than more mature felines. Nevertheless, three animals have been relocated because their personalities were incompatible or they otherwise upset the group’s equilibrium. One such case involved Obi, a ten-week-old kitten, who ultimately went to live with Price and her own companion animals after he began to persistently bother Nellie, Pearl, and Dot, a trio of entirely black sisters. Price reported that removing him from the situation allowed everything to return to its previous state of calm.

Image Credit - Freepik

From Care Homes to Cat Cafe Vision

Before the global health crisis, Price had a career in residential care facilities, where she organized music-focused activities. She conceived of The Cat House as a kind of neighborhood arts hub featuring resident felines. This concept is now apparent in its consistent offerings of art instruction and craft workshops, all cat-themed. In late 2021, over a five-day road trip, Price visited ten cat cafes and "learned that I didn’t want to do what they were doing."

Learning from Existing Cafe Models

Some establishments Price visited were on high streets or in shopping centres, with no outdoor access and continual disruption from passersby. Others seemed to prioritise the cafe above the cats, serving proper meals, not just snacks. It was clear that many cats weren’t thriving, Price says. “There were lots that were very timid and really didn’t want to be touched. You know when you go to stroke a cat, and they arch their back away? A lot of that was happening,” she observed during her research.

Establishing and Managing The Cat House

The Cat House opened in August 2023, after a long search for a sufficiently spacious, one-storey venue off the high street. Ensuring peace and harmony on the premises is a constant process of observation and adaptation, Price says. Each cat receives daily grooming, a weekly health check and monthly weighing, meaning there are regular opportunities to check for concerns, signs of stress or changes in mood. There is also extensive record-keeping to ensure consistency and communication across staffing changes – including a 20-point checklist for each cat. Price noted, "We write down any incidents – such as: ‘Roxy growled at Pearl’ – because it’s important."

Rules for Visitors and Feline Awareness

Patrons must also adhere to specific guidelines – chief among them, no feeding the cats or picking them up. The free-form “lounge sessions” are restricted to ages 10-plus, and 20 customers at a time. However, there are regular supervised “cat awareness sessions” for younger children to learn how to respectfully interact with cats, fostering better human-animal understanding from a young age.

A Call for Better Regulation, Not Closure

Price stated that the findings from the RSPCA and Cats Protection did not cause her alarm. She, too, has observed the swift and recent proliferation of feline coffee houses, even in Norfolk, and concurs that some might be better off closed. However, she firmly believes that increased supervision is necessary. Presently only some local authorities in England and Wales require cat cafes to be licensed and regularly inspected. Those that do tend to use regulations more typically applied to dog breeders, dog daycare and boarding kennels and catteries, so considerations specific to cat cafes can be lost.

Image Credit - Freepik

Proposals for a New Licensing Framework

Instead of phasing them out, Price says a point-based system could be created to prevent them from being opened in high-density areas, to cap cat numbers and account for beneficial factors such as outdoor access and environmental enrichment. “How much space have you got per cat? ... How big is your building? Can they climb?” says Price. Cat cafes could also be reimagined as add-ons to shelters or sanctuaries, more directly supporting rescue and rehoming efforts for animals in need.

Charities Maintain Firm Opposition

For Cats Protection and the RSPCA, however, the feline coffee house model is not an idea worth fighting for. They are urging the UK and Welsh governments to identify and stop all activities “that negatively affect the welfare of animals” as part of their review of licensing activities later this year. Cats Protection has also specifically requested an end to “cat yoga,” another activity involving felines in public settings.

Differing Models, Consistent Concerns for Welfare

Potter draws attention to the disagreement, even among cat cafe owners, over which approach is better for welfare – those with resident cats, or those that rehome them. “There are issues on both sides,” Potter says, “which is why we don’t think cat cafes are suitable for cats, full stop.” It may be possible to design and operate a venue that consistently meets all animals’ welfare needs, “but I think it’s very unlikely,” she says, expressing significant skepticism.

The Fundamental Tension: Cat Needs vs. Customer Expectations

Hoile shares this view. “We should be aiming for the best, for every cat … and it’s a hugely complicated area to get right, if we do stick with it.” There’s perhaps a fundamental tension, she suggests, between cats’ needs for escape routes, hiding places and plenty of space, and customers’ expectations of coffee with a side of cuddles. “You wouldn’t pay to go to a cat cafe and leave without seeing a cat,” she concluded, highlighting the central dilemma.