Animal Welfare Concerns Grow Over Foreign Dogs

Britain's Trojan Dogs: The Hidden Perils of the Pet Import Boom

A powerful image of a dog in a foreign shelter, posted with a heart-wrenching story, can be impossible for an animal lover to ignore. A few clicks, a payment, and a handful of weeks later, a new companion arrives, a life seemingly saved. This act of compassion, however, is increasingly the start of a nightmare for many British families. The unregulated, large-scale importation of rescue dogs is fuelling a crisis, unleashing dangerous diseases, unpredictable behaviours, and immense suffering on both humans and animals. Behind the feel-good narratives on social media lies a troubling reality of a system spiralling out of control, with devastating consequences for all involved.

An Unprecedented Influx

The scale of canine importation into Great Britain is staggering. In 2024 alone, a colossal 335,451 canines came into the country non-commercially under the Pet Travel Scheme (PETS), a system designed for genuine pet owners moving with their animals. This figure, which saw a peak of over 50,000 dogs in August, lays bare the enormous scale of the issue. Many of these are so-called "rescue" dogs, acquired through organisations that exploit this non-commercial route to bypass stricter commercial import regulations. This deluge of animals arrives with little oversight, creating a perfect storm for the problems now plaguing the nation's pet owners and veterinary services.

The Social Media Marketplace

The modern imported dog trade operates with the slick convenience of a delivery service. Animal welfare charities have grimly nicknamed it a 'canine delivery service'. Prospective owners scroll through heart-rending images on Facebook or other websites, falling for a picture and a tragic backstory. The process that follows is often deceptively straightforward, involving little more than a brief telephone chat, a simple digital form, and maybe a quick video tour of the residence. Weeks later, a van, often arriving late at night after a gruelling journey across Europe from countries like Romania or Ukraine, delivers a terrified, unknown animal directly to the door. This absence of a robust protocol for matching or face-to-face evaluation is a recipe for disaster.

A Regulatory Black Hole

A significant part of the problem stems from a glaring legislative gap. While entities rescuing animals in Scotland require a license to operate, no such legal requirement exists in Northern Ireland, Wales, or England. This regulatory vacuum allows a vast, unchecked market to flourish, with operators ranging from well-meaning but naive individuals to unscrupulous dealers prioritising profit over welfare. For years, campaigners have petitioned the government for action. An attempt to introduce stricter controls, the Animal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill, was abandoned in 2023, leaving a void that continues to be exploited. This failure to regulate has created a dangerous disparity and left the door open to the current crisis.

A Deadly Souvenir: The Rise of Brucella Canis

Among the gravest threats arriving with these imported dogs is Brucella canis, a bacterial infection with serious implications for both canine and human health. Once considered a rarity within Great Britain, its rapid spread is a direct consequence of the unregulated import market, presenting a significant public health challenge.

An Invisible Threat

This insidious bacterium spreads mainly via canine reproductive fluids and can trigger a range of debilitating symptoms in dogs, including infertility, stillbirths, and infections of the spine and joints. The disease is notoriously difficult to treat, as the bacteria can hide within the body's cells, making it resistant to antibiotics. For many infected dogs, the prognosis is poor, leading to a lifetime of health complications. The subtle nature of the infection means many dogs can be carriers without showing obvious outward signs, unknowingly spreading the disease.

From Rare to Rampant

The escalating number of Brucella canis cases highlights the severity of the import problem. Prior to the year 2020, a mere three confirmed canine infections were documented inside the UK. By 2024, that number had exploded, with 333 cases being actively investigated by authorities. This dramatic increase is not due to better detection alone; it serves as a plain indicator of a new and growing threat entering the country. Vets and scientists have directly linked this surge to the influx of dogs from regions in Eastern Europe where the disease is endemic. Each new case represents a failure of the current import system to protect the nation's biosecurity.

A Family's Nightmare

The story of Derbyshire resident Trudy Cain brings the clinical statistics into sharp focus. She believed she was doing a good deed by rescuing Nola, a dog from Romania. Sixteen weeks following Nola's arrival, Ms Cain was confronted with the devastating news that her new pet was positive for Brucella canis. She faced the heartbreaking recommendation from a vet to have Nola euthanized. Refusing to give up on an animal that seemed healthy, Ms Cain is now trapped in a cycle of worry, facing mounting vet bills and profound anxiety about the health of her family. Her experience demonstrates the immense emotional and financial toll the disease takes on compassionate owners.

The Human Connection

The likelihood of the illness passing from canines to people is thought to be minimal, but it is not zero. A minimum of one verified case of a dog owner contracting the illness has been recorded in Britain. In humans, Brucella canis can cause a serious and persistent illness with symptoms resembling influenza, including fever, muscle aches, and fatigue. In more severe instances, it can lead to long-term complications like arthritis or infections of the heart and nervous system. Dr Stephen Woolley, an expert in tropical medicine, characterized the illness as both "ignored and insufficiently researched," which highlights the potential for unknown risks as it becomes more prevalent.

Image Credit - Freepik

The Behavioural Time Bomb

Beyond the alarming health risks, many imported dogs arrive with deep-seated behavioural problems. These issues often stem from a traumatic past and the stress of a long-distance journey. For unsuspecting adopters, the dream of rescuing a dog can quickly sour into a challenging and sometimes dangerous reality.

A Legacy of Trauma

Countless rescued canines from abroad have endured harsh lives on the streets or in overcrowded shelters. This early-life trauma, combined with the gruelling, multi-day transit to Britain packed in a van, can leave lasting psychological scars. Canine behaviour expert Dr Rowena Packer warns that matching these animals with suitable homes is incredibly difficult without a clear history. She describes the process for adopters as a game of "Russian roulette". Well-meaning people who wish to provide aid are gambling on an animal's disposition whose past is a complete unknown, setting both the dog and the new family up for failure.

When Rescue Turns to Ruin

Sian Keen's experience is a stark illustration of this gamble. She agreed to take in Narla, a pregnant canine rescued from Ukraine. Shortly after Narla delivered her puppies, officials from trading standards seized all twelve dogs over fears of forged import documents. They were held in quarantine for three weeks as a safeguard to prevent a rabies outbreak. When Narla came back to the house, her disposition had altered radically. She became aggressive, attacking Ms Keen and her son. The bite Ms Keen sustained was severe, and it penetrated down to the muscle. The family felt they had no other option but to euthanize Narla, a traumatic end to what began as an act of kindness.

Unpredictable Aggression

The transformation of a seemingly gentle rescue dog into an aggressive animal is a recurring theme. The new environment of a home, with its strange sounds, enclosed spaces, and expectations of interaction, can be overwhelming for a canine that has never experienced it. Fear is often the root of this aggression. A canine that has had to fight for food or defend itself on the streets may react defensively when it feels threatened or confused. For families, especially those with children, this unpredictability poses a genuine risk, turning the home into a source of constant tension rather than companionship.

A System Built on Deception

The entire process of importing rescue dogs is rife with opportunities for deceit. From falsified health records to the misrepresentation of a dog's history, inadequate enforcement allows unscrupulous actors to profit from the compassion of UK citizens. This deception not only endangers individual families but also undermines the integrity of the UK's biosecurity controls.

The Forgery Loophole

The case of Narla, the canine from Ukraine, exposed a critical vulnerability in the system: forged documents. Her paperwork, along with that of 18 other dogs, was believed to have been falsified. The organisation involved, Paw Help UK, stated it was unaware of the forgeries, which it claimed came from a lab being utilized on a contingency footing after the war began. This single incident highlights how easily the system can be compromised. With thousands of animals entering the UK, the capacity to scrutinise every piece of paperwork is limited, creating a loophole which is exploitable for importing animals without the required health checks.

Bypassing the Rules

A fundamental flaw in the current system is the routine use of the non-commercial Pet Travel Scheme (PETS) for what are effectively commercial rescue operations. The scheme was intended for owners travelling with up to five of their own pets. However, it is now widely used by rescue groups to transport van loads of dogs for adoption. This disguises the commercial nature of the transaction, allowing them to avoid the more stringent health and welfare checks required for commercial imports. This misuse of the system is a primary driver of the current crisis, enabling the mass movement of animals with minimal oversight.

Image Credit - Freepik

A New Hope for Regulation?

After years of campaigning by animal welfare charities, there is finally a glimmer of hope on the legislative horizon. A new bill is making its way through Parliament that aims to tackle the worst excesses of the import trade and close some of the most dangerous loopholes.

A Bill to Heal Old Wounds

The Animal Welfare (Import of Dogs, Cats and Ferrets) Bill, a Private Member's Bill introduced by Selaine Saxby MP and supported by the government, seeks to address the crisis head-on. The Bill represents the most significant attempt in years to tighten the rules. Its progress to the House of Lords has been welcomed by charities like the RSPCA and Dogs Trust, who have been instrumental in highlighting the cruelty of the trade. They see it as a vital step towards ending the suffering of countless dogs caught up in this damaging industry.

Closing the Gaps

The Bill proposes several crucial changes to the current regulations. It would raise the minimum import age for puppies from 15 weeks to six months, making them less desirable to impulse buyers and ensuring they are more immunologically robust. Furthermore, it would ban the import of heavily pregnant dogs, preventing them from enduring stressful journeys in late-term pregnancy. Crucially, the legislation would also stop the import of dogs with mutilations like cropped ears or docked tails, a measure designed to stamp out the demand for these cruel cosmetic procedures.

A Vet's Plea

Dr Danny Chambers, a Liberal Democrat MP and a vet, has been a vocal supporter of the new legislation. Drawing on his professional experience, he described puppy smuggling as "unimaginably cruel". He pointed to the severe welfare implications of separating young animals from their mothers and transporting them in substandard conditions simply for profit. Dr Chambers also highlighted the role of social media influencers in driving demand for dogs with cropped ears, a practice many people do not realise is a painful mutilation. His expert voice has added significant weight to the call for reform.

Image Credit - Freepik

The Unintended Consequences

The relentless focus on rescuing dogs from abroad has had a damaging, if unintended, impact on animal welfare within the UK. Domestic rescue centres are facing unprecedented pressures, while thousands of deserving local dogs are being overlooked by potential adopters who are captivated by the allure of foreign rescue.

Overlooked at Home

A troubling trend has emerged in recent years. According to the PDSA, the proportion of owners acquiring their dog from a UK-based rescue centre has fallen. In 2024, only 12% of dogs came from this source, down from 18% before the pandemic. In contrast, a significant number of people are turning to foreign rescues. This has created an adoption paradox: while UK shelters are full to bursting, many potential homes are being offered to dogs from overseas. The result is that healthy, well-adjusted British dogs are being left behind, facing longer stays in kennels or an uncertain future.

The Ripple Effect

UK-based animal charities are increasingly finding themselves on the frontline, dealing with the fallout from failed foreign adoptions. Emma Shaffery, who works with Forest Dog Rescue in Worcestershire, explains her organisation's role as dealing with the aftermath of irresponsible rescue groups. When an imported dog proves too difficult to handle, owners often turn to their local shelter for help. This places an additional, unfunded burden on these charities, which are already struggling with a national crisis of pet relinquishment driven by the rising cost of living. They are forced to use their limited resources to care for animals imported by other organisations.

A Vow for Welfare

When confronted with the scale of the problem, a Defra representative has affirmed that every animal rescue entity is required to "comply with legal welfare standards." The department also points to voluntary schemes, suggesting that citizens are able to verify if a group belongs to the Association of Dogs and Cats Homes, a body which has its own set of standards. However, critics argue these measures are insufficient. Without a mandatory, legally enforced licensing system for all of the UK, there is little to stop rogue operators from continuing to exploit animals and the public.

A Call for Conscious Compassion

The crisis of imported dogs is a complex issue born from a mixture of good intentions, criminal exploitation, and regulatory failure. The desire to save an animal's life is a noble one, but the current system has turned this compassion into a dangerous gamble. The influx of animals with unknown histories and serious health and behavioural problems poses a threat not only to the dogs themselves but to the wider pet population and to public health. The proposed Animal Welfare Bill offers a genuine chance to curb the worst aspects of this trade, but legislation alone is not a panacea.

A cultural shift is also required. Prospective owners must recognise the risks of sourcing a pet online from another country. They should be encouraged to look first to the thousands of deserving dogs waiting in UK shelters. True compassion must be conscious and informed, ensuring that the act of saving one animal does not lead to suffering for many others.