La Guajira wind farms impact the Wayuu community

Winds of Change: La Guajira's Green Energy Drive Challenges Wayuu Heritage 

Emerging from his dwelling within Colombia's northern La Guajira territory, José Luis Iguarán witnesses a radically different scene. A sequence of ten colossal wind turbines now stands out against the cactus-filled landscape, extending toward waters of the Caribbean. This modification to the scenery reflects a larger transition underway throughout the dry peninsula. Mr Iguarán is part of the indigenous Wayuu people, who have occupied this land for centuries. Their established customs encompass raising goats, tending modest crops, gathering salt from deposits, and fishing along the coast. This deep ancestral link makes the abrupt installation of industrial power infrastructure feel particularly disruptive. Familiar tree shapes have yielded to the spinning blades and unceasing drone of turbines, changing the everyday sensory reality for his settlement. This situation represents merely the start; La Guajira currently contains one functioning wind installation, Guajira 1, while fifteen more undergo construction, alongside proposals for potentially scores of others. The sheer magnitude promises considerable transformation. 

Wayuu Culture and Connection to Territory 

The Wayuu population, approximately 380,000 strong within Colombia and reaching into Venezuela, holds a unique cultural and spiritual legacy closely bound to their ancestral areas. Wayuu society frequently follows maternal lineage, meaning land rights and social structure transfer through the mother’s relations. This parched, demanding environment influenced their perspective over many generations. For them, the land represents more than a simple asset; it constitutes a hallowed domain inhabited by ancestral spirits, crucial to their core identity. Burial grounds and various specific locations possess immense spiritual weight. Their cosmology features an intricate bond with the natural world; elements such as the wind are not viewed as inert phenomena but contain life and individuality. This deep-seated connection signifies that any alteration to the terrain influences not only the physical surroundings but also the complex network of spiritual ties the Wayuu uphold with their setting. Safeguarding this bond remains vital for their cultural continuation. 

Image Credit - BBC

Colombia's Renewable Energy Ambitions 

La Guajira, endowed with some of the nation's most potent and reliable wind currents, finds itself positioned as a central point for the country's energy evolution. The administration intends to move away from non-renewable energy sources towards sustainable alternatives, motivated by climate pledges and the requirement for energy stability. Colombia’s power generation system traditionally depended significantly on hydroelectric facilities, leaving it exposed during dry spells. Wind and solar power introduce diversity, although wind power presently makes up a minimal portion (roughly 0.1%) of the countrywide total. Governmental strategies anticipate considerable growth. La Guajira should eventually accommodate numerous wind installations generating possibly above 8 gigawatts (GW) by 2034, representing a large segment of Colombia’s present overall capacity. This potential firmly situates the area, and the Wayuu homeland within it, directly aligned with national advancement objectives, inevitably creating friction with existing land practices and customs. 

The Disturbance of Dreams and Daily Life 

The establishment of wind power facilities introduces palpable interruptions into Wayuu settlements. Mr Iguarán emphasizes the continuous sounds the turbines produce, especially during nighttime hours. He clarifies this persistent hum disrupts sleep patterns and affects dreams. From a Wayuu standpoint, dreams transcend mere subconscious workings; they regard them as a hallowed pathway into the spiritual dimension. They believe dreams deliver crucial communications and direction originating with past generations, which families then decipher. The sonic interference from the turbines consequently affects a fundamental element of their spiritual observance and linkage to their heritage. Apart from the spiritual dimension, the tangible existence of the turbines reshapes the visual and sonic atmosphere. Industrial sights and sounds supplant natural ones, serving as a constant signal of the external dynamics remodelling their ancestral territory and established life patterns. This generates an unsettling element in their day-to-day lives. 

Development's Tangible Gains 

Although cultural practices face interruption, certain advantages have materialized for groups like Mr Iguarán’s. Isagen, the Colombian corporation managing Guajira 1 (under the control of Canadian firm Brookfield asset management), allocated funds for vital upgrades. These encompass provision of safe potable water sources, enhanced local road networks improving mobility, and the building of robust dwellings made of brick. These new residences provide superior durability compared to some conventional structures built using mud and cactus elements. Additionally, Isagen furnishes yearly compensation to a trio of nearby settlements for accommodating the power installation infrastructure. These groups also obtain a proportional share of the annual income derived from electricity transactions plus a segment originating from carbon credit dealings; businesses acquire these credits to counterbalance their own greenhouse gas output. Mr Iguarán perceives possibilities within such initiatives to supply essential development impetus to one of the nation's most impoverished areas, presenting infrastructure lacking for generations. 

Seeds of Discord: Transparency and Fairness Concerns 

Nonetheless, positive feelings about wind energy development are not universally shared among the Wayuu. Aaron Laguna, who fishes for a living and resides at the seaside settlement Cabo de la Vela, expresses significant reservations. While recognizing the clean power generation, he highlights the discord these initiatives foster within Wayuu society. His own locality presently engages in consultation processes concerning a proposed wind power facility nearby. Mr Laguna indicates observing extensive discontent among populations impacted by current projects. Frequent grievances mention insufficient openness from power corporations, unsatisfactory payment for land utilization and disturbance, perceived disregard for Wayuu societal customs, and accusations of corruption linked to talks and benefit allocation. He further notes that ineffective negotiation methods can result in poor handling of the assistance that does arrive locally. These matters cultivate suspicion and resistance, hindering possible cooperation between developers and residents. 

Image Credit - BBC

The Challenge of Consultation and Consent 

The procedure intended to uphold indigenous entitlements, termed Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (FPIC), encounters substantial difficulties within the La Guajira area. Colombian legislation mandates FPIC, obliging developers to secure accords with affected populations. These agreements must address financial advantages and redress for socio-environmental consequences. Yet, Wayuu leaders and settlement members contend these discussions frequently feel hurried or inadequate. Corporations occasionally arrive without invitation, commencing procedures before the community is properly prepared. Apprehensions exist that governmental bodies might sometimes prioritise easing company entry over safeguarding community welfare. Moreover, the intricate Wayuu societal framework, where authority rests with particular maternal lineages and customary figures, can be misinterpreted or sidestepped by firms pursuing faster agreements. This sometimes results in arrangements made with persons lacking complete community backing. Such practices erode the foundation of informed agreement and promote conflict, possibly rendering agreements invalid later. 

A Fraught History and the Spectre of 'Wind Wars' 

Present frictions mirror past struggles across La Guajira connected to resource acquisition. Several decades prior, the entry of petroleum companies ignited fierce inter-clan clashes regarding land governance for negotiation privileges, locally known as the "gas wars". Comparable disputes surfaced during the creation of the huge El Cerrejón open-cast coal mine. Joanna Barney, affiliated with Indepaz, a Colombian analysis group, identifies worrying indicators of emergent "wind wars". Indepaz possesses records of violent clashes, occasionally within kin groups, concerning bargaining authority with wind enterprises, allegedly causing fatalities. Setting up road obstructions, a frequent protest tactic employed when inhabitants feel disregarded, interfered with initiatives such as Guajira 1. Aggressions targeting energy firm personnel, encompassing incidents involving armed theft and abduction, have also been documented. Furthermore, reports exist detailing people forced to move and hostility among communities disagreeing about adjacent developments. This background casts a significant shadow across the ongoing energy evolution, fostering an atmosphere of distrust. 

Deepening Divisions and Corporate Departures 

Arguments surrounding wind initiatives have caused major impediments for developers. In May 2023, Enel, an enterprise based in Italy, relinquished its intended Windpeshi wind installation. The company cited persistent demonstrations that significantly obstructed building work during the period 2021 to 2023. Subsequently, in December 2024, the Spanish corporation EDP Renováveis put aside proposals for a pair of wind projects planned for La Guajira. EDP stated the ventures lacked financial feasibility, partially because the count of nearby native groups asserting impacts and requesting compensation had increased twofold. These withdrawals underscore the considerable hazards corporations encounter stemming from unresolved social tensions and population resistance. The assumption that 'green' initiatives are inherently positive without rigorous social impact evaluation faces scrutiny. The deficit in sturdy legal structures to evaluate social consequences intensifies the issue. These corporate withdrawals indicate the monetary and operational challenges born from insufficient community participation and unsettled complaints, potentially discouraging subsequent investment within that territory. 

Two Worlds, One Wind: Divergent Perceptions 

Wieldler Guerra, who studies cultures in Colombia, emphasizes a basic failure of comprehension separating Wayuu perspectives from those of the energy firms. He portrays the situation as a dialogue between distinct realities occurring without achieving shared understanding. This difference also covers how they conceive of the wind itself. In the Wayuu worldview, winds are not inert assets but living forces, comparable to persons. Their traditions acknowledge numerous separate winds, frequently eight. These are regarded as figures from myth and ancestry possessing specific characteristics influencing the environment, demanding reverence. Wayuu cosmology perceives wind as the creator's breath, an essential energy linking sky, earth, and spirit, transporting communications and prayers. Conversely, corporate entities and the Colombian administration predominantly regard wind as a physical asset exploitable to advance environmental goals, secure energy supplies, and generate economic gain. This fundamental clash of understanding complicates discussions and mutual appreciation, frequently causing project postponements and disagreements over sacred locations. 

Image Credit - BBC

National Energy Needs vs. Local Realities 

Colombia seeks to broaden its power generation sources, presently dominated by hydroelectric facilities (supplying almost two-thirds of the national output). This dependency renders the nation susceptible to power deficits during dry spells when reservoir capacities diminish. Wind power, notwithstanding La Guajira's immense potential (projected between 15-21 GW), contributes very little presently. The administration views expanding wind capacity as essential for national energy stability and fulfilling climate objectives. They aim for substantial growth in non-conventional renewable energy (NCRE) generation. Nevertheless, progress encounters obstacles. Delays in obtaining permits alongside social disagreements have impeded advancement; Colombia appears likely to miss its ambitious 6GW NCRE goal set for 2026. While nationwide targets propel the drive for wind installations, local populations contest the allocation of advantages and the precedence given to national requirements over regional consequences. They feel their apprehensions are frequently ignored within the larger geopolitical energy plan. 

Company Strategies and Calls for Government Support 

Power firms putting capital into the area, such as AES Colombia, currently constructing a substantial six-installation wind complex, declare they pursue sustained conversation involving local groups. They highlight offering equitable payment plus guaranteeing concrete advantages like safe potable water access and portions of carbon credit income. AES intends to commence building its extensive Jemeiwaa Ka'l project after receiving environmental clearance for a vital transmission line. However, Federico Echavarría, holding the general manager role at AES Colombia, concedes that positive local interactions alone prove inadequate. He underlines the necessity for governmental action to assist in mediating and settling disagreements separating distinct Wayuu communities. These conflicts often emerge concerning land entitlements, representation, and the distribution of benefits. Corporations acknowledge that navigating the intricate social terrain demands governmental assistance complementing their own outreach initiatives to avert project derailment caused by internal community divisions. 

A Legacy of State Neglect 

Aaron Laguna’s viewpoint from the Cabo de la Vela location mirrors a wider feeling across La Guajira: a background of disregard from the Colombian state. The area endures chronically insufficient funding for schooling provision and medical services. Obtaining fundamental utilities like piped water continues to be a significant hurdle, especially within rural districts. Numerous inhabitants, particularly those in scattered settlements, still travel considerable distances daily gathering water at traditional reservoirs known as jagüeys, which rely on rainfall. This deficit in essential infrastructure and governmental presence starkly contrasts with the massive investments directed towards energy initiatives. The Wayuu experience high rates of poverty alongside acute difficulties concerning food availability and inadequate nutrition. Environmental conditions and restricted economic possibilities exacerbate these issues. This situation nurtures doubt regarding whether newfound energy prosperity will yield substantial enhancements for residents or merely enrich external organizations. 

The Paradox of Power Generation 

A major area of dispute for numerous Wayuu involves the ultimate use related to the power the turbines on their territory generate. Mr Laguna bemoans the contradiction: despite accommodating huge power production projects, his settlement at Cabo de la Vela, similar to many countryside communities, fails to obtain grid electricity. They maintain dependence upon expensive and polluting generators for their energy requirements, at minimum for the immediate future. Plans dictate transmitting the generated energy to Colombia's national system, delivering power to different parts of the country. This circumstance nurtures sensations of being exploited – enduring the interruptions from the power installations without gaining directly from the main asset they yield. While certain populations negotiate for infrastructure upgrades such as water treatment facilities, the absence of direct energy supply persists as a potent emblem of disparity, fueling local animosity towards these large undertakings. 

Environmental Considerations and Biodiversity 

Separate from the social and cultural consequences, extensive wind energy development introduces ecological queries within La Guajira's distinct ecosystem. The parched terrain, while appearing barren, sustains particular plants and animals adapted to its environment. The building footprint associated with turbines and service routes modifies habitats. Worries arise regarding potential collision hazards for birds and bats traversing the vicinity. Bats perform a vital function pollinating indigenous flora like the cardón cactus. Although promoted as 'clean' power, the industrial magnitude of wind installations inevitably affects the surrounding environment. Thorough environmental impact studies must meticulously weigh these outcomes alongside the social factors. Achieving equilibrium between renewable power objectives, biodiversity safeguarding, and preserving the Wayuu's natural inheritance necessitates careful forethought and mitigation tactics. These must integrate into project planning and consultative procedures to curtail long-term ecological harm. 

Image Credit - BBC

Navigating Benefit Sharing and Equity 

Achieving a genuinely "just transition" demands equitable and clear allocation of the financial gains produced through wind initiatives. At present, benefit distribution agreements display considerable variation between different projects and even among settlements affected by the identical project. A deficit exists concerning standardized rules dictating how advantages are allocated and overseen. Accords might encompass single payments, yearly charges, proportions of income, or financing for designated community undertakings like educational facilities or wells. Nevertheless, apprehensions continue regarding the sufficiency of these advantages and the clarity concerning how finances are administered after community representatives receive them. Devising unambiguous, fair, and culturally suitable mechanisms for sharing benefits, formulated via authentic consultation and potentially governed with greater rigor, proves essential for cultivating trust. It also helps ensure projects positively influence local sustainable progress instead of worsening pre-existing disparities. 

The Path Towards Collaborative Solutions 

Tackling the intricate difficulties within this specific territory requires moving past confrontational approaches toward more cooperative frameworks. Bolstering the FPIC procedure remains crucial. This means ensuring consultations happen promptly, are culturally sensitive, furnish thorough details (using local tongues like Wayuunaiki), and acknowledge customary leadership structures. Formulating standardized systems for distributing benefits could foster fairness and clarity. Governmental bodies must assume a more proactive function, not solely advocating for projects but also mediating disagreements, enforcing adherence to rules, and safeguarding indigenous entitlements. Corporations need to embrace genuinely participatory methods, regarding communities as collaborators rather than impediments. Certain Wayuu factions have even put forward their own autonomous consultation guidelines, insisting on acknowledgment of their worldview and rights from the beginning. Establishing trust demands persistent exertion, reciprocal respect, plus a dedication to confirming the shift in energy sourcing advantages all parties fairly. 

Looking Ahead: An Uncertain Future 

La Guajira's trajectory remains undecided, positioned between the allure of renewable energy riches and the risk of intensifying social rifts and cultural erosion. Colombia’s drive for decarbonisation holds importance, yet its execution here underscores a worldwide challenge: pursuing green advancement without repeating historic marginalisation patterns impacting indigenous populations. The Wayuu community indicates readiness for development but insists on deference towards their entitlements, homeland, and traditions. Realizing an authentically "just energy transition" across La Guajira demands more than mere technological implementation. It calls for fundamental alterations in how progress is conceptualized and carried out. Prioritising human rights, cultural wholeness, ecological sustainability, and just benefit allocation is paramount. Absent such transformations, the air currents sweeping the peninsula might persist in delivering as much disruption as power. This could leave the original inhabitants potentially overlooked by advancement yet again, observing resources depart their territory with minimal advantage returning locally.