Climate Crisis Grips The Swiss Alps

The Crumbling Crown: Can Switzerland Rescue Its Alpine Soul from the Meltdown?

Within a tiny community in the striking valley of Loetschental, Matthias Bellwald strolls along the central road. At every turn, locals offer him a smile, a warm handshake, or a kind greeting. Although Mr Bellwald holds a mayoral position, this community is not his own. His home, Blatten, located just three miles from here, was wiped from existence two months prior. A catastrophic event saw a section of the mountain alongside its glacier collapse directly into the valley floor, burying the village completely.

All three hundred of the village's inhabitants were evacuated to safety days prior to the event. Geologists issued timely warnings that the mountain's structure was becoming perilously unstable. Despite the successful evacuation, Blatten's former residents lost everything. Their homes disappeared. Their church, local hotels, and farms were all gone, swallowed by the earth in a matter of moments, leaving a void where a community once thrived.

A Legacy Lost in Rubble

Lukas Kalbermatten feels the loss with profound sharpness. He lost the establishment that was a cornerstone of his family for three generations. The hotel was more than a building; it was a repository of history and memory. He speaks of the village's unique atmosphere, the web of small alleys that wound between the traditional houses, and the central church. These were the places that held the memories of childhood games and community gatherings. Now, he explains, everything has now vanished completely.

Today, Mr Kalbermatten resides in temporary lodging within the neighbouring Wiler village. A provisional office is also where Mr Bellwald works. From this temporary base, he shoulders the immense responsibility of overseeing the enormous clearing operation. Beyond that, he oversees the plans for a potential rebuild, a project of hope against a backdrop of devastation.

Life in Limbo

The immediate future for Blatten's displaced residents is defined by profound uncertainty. They live scattered across the valley, relying on the generosity of neighbouring communities. The rhythm of daily life has been shattered. The familiar comfort of home has been replaced by the unsettling feeling of temporary existence. For a large number of them, the psychological toll is immense, grappling with the trauma of the event and the loss of their physical connection to generations of family history.

Mayor Bellwald's work involves not just logistical challenges but also providing a focal point for a scattered and grieving community. He coordinates with engineers, communicates with former residents, and navigates the complex bureaucracy of disaster relief. Every decision is freighted with the weight of his community's future.

The Billion-Pound Question

There is some good news amid the despair. The mayor is optimistic that the location can be cleared of debris by 2028. He holds onto the hope that the initial new residences could be ready for families to move into by 2029. This vision of rebirth, however, is attached to a staggering price tag. The estimated cost of rebuilding Blatten runs into a cost in the hundreds of millions of pounds, possibly reaching £800,000 per resident. This figure has ignited a national conversation.

Donations from the Swiss public rapidly accumulated millions of francs. The funds were a testament to national solidarity, aimed at helping the people who were displaced. Additionally, the national government along with the regional canton pledged significant financial support. Yet, some voices in Switzerland have begun to ask a difficult question: is it truly worth it?

A Nation on Unstable Ground

The disaster in Blatten shocked the nation, but it highlighted a much larger, systemic threat. Roughly two-thirds of Switzerland's territory is mountainous. Climate scientists have issued increasingly urgent warnings. Ice flows and frozen ground, the substrate that acts as a kind of mountain cement, are thawing at an alarming rate. As global temperatures continue to rise, this thaw makes catastrophic rockfalls more probable throughout the Alpine region. Protecting every vulnerable area will be prohibitively expensive.

Switzerland already spends nearly £400 million annually on defensive infrastructure like avalanche barriers and rockfall nets. A report commissioned for the national parliament of Switzerland in 2007 suggested that providing genuine, comprehensive protection against guarding against natural dangers might cost six times that amount. This presents a painful dilemma: is this a sensible use of funds, or ought the nation consider the agonising choice of forsaking some of its cherished villages to the forces of nature?

Image Credit - Freepik

Brienz: The Ghost Village

The story of Brienz offers a chilling, real-world parallel. This village in the Graubünden region was cleared of its population over two years ago. Geologists detected dangerous signs of precariousness of the mountain looming directly above the community. The inhabitants are still unable to go back to their homes permanently. Last July, after a period of heavy rainfall swept across Switzerland, geologists alerted that a significant rockslide seemed on the verge of occurring.

A significant portion of the unstable slope did collapse, but miraculously, it missed the village itself. This near-miss allowed some residents to return, but their lives are now governed by constant monitoring and the ever-present threat of another, more direct, catastrophe. Brienz has become a symbol of the precariousness of life in the modern Alps.

More Tremors in the Alps

The threat is not isolated. In another Swiss location, above the well-known Kandersteg resort in the Bernese Oberland, an enormous cliff face has grown precarious. This instability poses a direct threat to the community below, and residents now live with a detailed evacuation plan at the ready. Heavy summer rains this year once again triggered fresh alerts. Authorities closed several hiking trails leading towards Oeschinen Lake, a major tourist attraction, as a precaution.

Sometimes, these incidents result in fatalities. A huge rockslide in 2017 descended close to Bondo village, which tragically took the lives of eight hikers. Bondo has since been rebuilt and heavily refortified, an effort that cost over £50 million. As early as 2003, Pontresina village invested millions in a defensive barrier to reinforce thawing permafrost.

A Climate Fingerprint

Blatten's inhabitants, understandably focused on their immediate future, are reluctant to discuss a warming climate. They emphasize that the Alpine region has always been a dangerous environment. Many characterize the catastrophe as a once-in-a-millennium event, a freak occurrence of nature. Their priority is not to attribute blame but to reclaim their lives and rebuild their community as swiftly as possible. This perspective is common in frontline communities.

However, climate scientists argue that ignoring the influence of rising global temperatures is a serious error. A leading glaciologist, Matthias Huss from the Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich and the monitoring organization GLAMOS, is clear. He argues that the Blatten event was influenced by climatic shifts, creating the conditions that made the collapse not just possible, but likely.

The Science of the Collapse

Mr Huss explains the complex mechanics of the event. Meltwater from permafrost at extreme altitudes was the primary trigger, which triggered the failure of the mountain's summit. This entire peak then fell upon the glacier below. The glacier itself, already weakened and in retreat due to warmer temperatures, was less able to stabilise the mountainside than it had been in the past. Mr Huss concedes that other geological changes were also a factor.

But he emphasises that the warming climate was a component in every aspect. His team at GLAMOS has documented a historic reduction in Swiss glaciers in recent times. In the two years leading before the catastrophe, they lost the same amount of ice as in the three decades prior to 1990.

When the Freezing Line Vanishes

Mean temperatures in the Alps are rising at roughly twice the global average. A particularly stark indicator of this trend occurred in the period just before the Blatten mountain collapse. The zero-degree line in Switzerland, the altitude at which the air reaches freezing, climbed beyond 5,000 meters. This is higher than any mountain peak in the entire country, including the iconic Mont Blanc. The entire Alpine landscape was, for a time, above freezing.

Mr Huss notes that while large landslides are not new to the Alps, their nature is changing. In his opinion, the most troubling trend is the increasing regularity of these incidents. Crucially, they are also becoming far more unpredictable, making it harder for scientists to provide the kind of specific, timely warnings that saved the residents of Blatten.

A Challenge to Alpine Identity

Following the Blatten catastrophe, a wave of sympathy and solidarity swept across Switzerland. The public response was immediate and generous. However, as the colossal price tag for rebuilding became clear, a more critical national debate began to surface. The respected Neue Zürcher Zeitung published an editorial that challenged the country's traditional wealth distribution model. This constitutional model channels tax revenue from city hubs such as Zurich to sustain outlying, and frequently vulnerable, mountain populations.

The piece argued that with such incidents growing more common because of climatic shifts, the public's readiness to fund what it termed "the myth of the Alps" is being severely tested. It suggested that this myth, so central to national identity, is now colliding with a harsh new economic and environmental reality.

The ‘Empathy Trap’ Accusation

The newspaper's editorial went further, describing the country's political figures as being "ensnared by an empathy trap." It suggested that emotional responses were preventing a rational discussion regarding what comes next. The most contentious section of the piece was its direct suggestion that individuals residing in the riskiest parts in the Alpine region ought to seriously consider relocation. This idea, while pragmatic to some, strikes at the very heart of Swiss culture and history.

While it wasn't the first time the Neue Zürcher Zeitung had raised doubts about the expense of preserving each Alpine settlement, its blunt tone angered many. Three-quarters of the Swiss population may reside in cities, but a great number of them maintain strong family and emotional links to the mountain areas. Their background is agricultural, defined by impoverished circumstances and hardship.

Image Credit - Freepik

The Deep Roots of ‘Heimat’

Resisting the idea of relocation requires understanding the Swiss-German concept of "Heimat." Lukas Kalbermatten clarifies that the term holds profound significance within Switzerland. It is not about a mere house or hometown. Heimat, he says, is a feeling connected to childhood memories, the places one played, and the people one grew up with. He insists it is a concept far more extensive than the word 'home.'

If you inquire of a Swiss person who has spent years in Zurich, Geneva, or even New York about their Heimat, many will not name their current city. Their answer will be the hamlet of their birth. The Kalbermatten siblings, all city dwellers today, consider their heimat to be the Loetschental valley, where the distinctive dialect is still spoken.

Losing More Than Homes

There is a significant concern that if population decline continues in these valleys, other singular elements of mountain culture may vanish permanently. The dialect, Leetschär, is one such element. For the Kalbermatten siblings, it is the language they all still use in their dreams. This linguistic heritage is woven into their identity and is inseparable from the place itself. The destruction of the village is also a threat to the language's survival.

This pattern of cultural erosion has precedents. Citing certain cases, Mr Kalbermatten points to remote areas in northern Italy where this has already occurred. He paints a stark picture of what could await abandoned valleys: empty houses, deserted villages, and the return of wolves. He asks, "Is that the future we desire?"

The Fading Cry of the Tschäggättä

Another example is the Tschäggättä, the customary carved masks found only in the Loetschental valley. Their origins are mysterious, possibly dating back to pagan traditions. Each February, the area's young men don the carved masks, which feature grotesque faces with horsehair and big teeth. They wear heavy animal hides and race through the lanes, a wild and intimidating presence that is a core element of the local carnival celebrations.

This tradition is not a performance for tourists; it is a vibrant element of the valley's identity. It connects the current generation to a long, unbroken line of ancestors. If the young men and their families leave, who will carve the masks? Who will run through the lanes? A concern exists that the silence of depopulation will extinguish these vibrant cultural flames.

The Myth of Taming Nature

Boris Previsic, who leads the Institute for the Culture of the Alps at the University of Lucerne, remarks that a large number of Swiss citizens, especially in urban areas, once felt they had conquered the Alpine landscape. The nation's train lines, tunnels, cableways, and elevated mountain routes are marvels of engineering. They stand as monuments to human ingenuity and our ability to connect and control even the most forbidding landscapes.

Now, Mr Previsic proposes, that self-assurance has evaporated, partly due to a shifting climate. The idea that infrastructure alone could conquer the mountains has been proven false. He argues that human-induced geology is simply too powerful for human beings to control.

A New Humility

Mr Previsic states, "People in Switzerland once believed infrastructure could solve anything. Today, I feel we are at a new starting point regarding that belief." The destruction of a village like Blatten, which had existed for eight centuries, delivered a particularly brutal shock to the national psyche. If a community with such deep roots could be wiped out so suddenly, then nowhere felt truly secure. This is what he finds so profoundly unsettling.

From his perspective, the moment has arrived to prevent these villages from disappearing. He does not advocate for blind rebuilding but for a smarter, more adaptable approach. He clarifies that this fight requires better preparation and increased adaptability, stressing that evacuation must always remain an option.

The Mountain Always Decides

In Wiler's temporary hub, Mr. Previsic’s assessment is acknowledged with a knowing, tired smile, reflecting a deep-seated grasp of nature's power. "The mountain is the ultimate arbiter," Mayor Bellwald concurs. It is a sentiment born from generations of living with immense natural forces. He says they are aware of the dangers and love the mountains regardless; they do not resent them for it. He reflects that their ancestors, and future generations, will all live with this truth.

This philosophy is not one of defeat, but of respect and coexistence. It is a recognition that life in the Alpine region has always involved a negotiation with risk. The terms of that negotiation, however, are now changing rapidly.

A Hub of Grim Activity

During the noon meal at a Wiler restaurant, the tables are occupied by the key people involved in the Blatten recovery efforts. Teams of cleanup workers, engineers in high-visibility jackets, and helicopter crews fill the room. The air buzzes with technical conversations and logistical planning. The recovery work is at its peak, a massive human effort directed at a wound in the landscape.

At a separate table, a representative from a major Swiss insurance firm sits alone. Periodically, he is joined by another party: an older couple, a man in his middle years, a young woman. He purchases a beverage for each of them. He listens intently, carefully recording information about their lost property and livelihoods, cataloguing the human cost one story at a time.

Image Credit - Freepik

Life Histories Under the Rock

Outside the restaurant, the valley’s narrow, winding roads are busy. A constant stream of trucks and bulldozers trundles toward the location of the disaster. Helicopters fly above, transporting massive pieces of wreckage. The immensity of the job is staggering. Even the Swiss military has been mobilised, a sign of the national significance of the recovery effort.

The commander of the army's disaster relief battalion is Sebastian Neuhaus. He observes the scene with a soldier's pragmatism but speaks with a poet's sensitivity. They must continue their work, he says, despite the immense challenge. He says it is a necessity because three hundred individual life stories are buried under the rubble.

The Unbreakable Human Bond

Amid the dust, the noise, and the grief, the prevailing emotion among the survivors is a resolute determination to carry on. A common trauma has created an even tighter connection among the past residents of Blatten. The community may have lost its physical location, but its spirit remains intact, perhaps stronger than before. They are united in their loss and in their resolve to endure.

Mr Kalbermatten shares, "When we encounter another person from Blatten, we embrace." It is a simple gesture, but it communicates everything. It is an acknowledgement of their shared experience and their continued existence. It is a way of holding onto each other when everything else has been swept away.

Everyone Has Survived

Sometimes, in those moments of embrace, a simple phrase is exchanged. "It is good you have survived," they say to one another. In these words lies the core of their resilience. They are without their houses and possessions, and their physical heritage. Yet, they have not lost each other. The disaster took the village, but it did not take the people.

As Switzerland confronts its precarious Alpine future, grappling with immense financial costs and existential questions about its identity, Blatten's former inhabitants hold onto this fundamental truth. He finishes by saying this is the most critical fact: "All of us have survived."