Startup Funding India Needs Shift Now

Minister Goyal Sparks Debate on India's Startup Landscape

India's Commerce Minister, Piyush Goyal, ignited a heated online debate with his remarks on the nation's burgeoning startup scene. Speaking at Startup Mahakumbh, a government-backed startup conference, Goyal appeared to criticise consumer-focused Indian startups. He encouraged entrepreneurs to strive for technological advancements benefiting the country as a whole. He highlighted the rise of food delivery services, niche retail brands, and online gaming platforms. Goyal compared these ventures to developments in another country, widely believed to be China. This other country has seen progress in machine learning, robotics, and the establishment of advanced manufacturing facilities capable of global competition. He pointed out that Indian startups often concentrate on products like artisanal ice cream.

His comments triggered responses from India's entrepreneurial community. Some contended that Goyal was simply advocating for more ambitious goals. Others viewed his words as an unfair assessment of the startup sector, a crucial component of India's economic system. Goyal also praised India's rapid startup growth. He recognised its status as the world's third-largest startup ecosystem. The minister urged domestic investors to increase their support for homegrown innovators. Despite this praise, he expressed a desire for accelerated progress. The Commerce Minister stressed the necessity of continuous learning and development. He asserted that further progress requires greater boldness and a willingness to compete. Goyal directly asked attendees whether their aim was to create technologically complex components or confectionery.

Zepto Co-founder Responds to Goyal's Critique

Zepto quick-commerce app co-founder, Aadit Palicha, swiftly countered Goyal's remarks. In a digital post, Palicha argued that online, consumer-centric businesses have consistently driven technological innovation both in India and globally. He cited Amazon, which started as an online bookstore, as an example. Amazon went on to pioneer cloud computing, among other accomplishments. He also mentioned current leaders in artificial intelligence, such as Facebook and Google. These companies initially served individual consumers as well. Palicha advocated for domestic investors to support consumer-facing businesses. This support would allow them to expand and allocate resources toward more advanced technological objectives. Palicha believes that nurturing consumer-facing startups will benefit technological advancement in the long run.

Investment Challenges in High-Tech Startups

Prominent investor Mohandas Pai highlighted a gap in venture capital funding for high-tech startups. In an interview with Economic Times Now, Pai revealed a preference among both state-owned and private investors for non-essential businesses. He explained that investors favour these businesses due to faster financial returns. High-tech advancements, however, require substantial time and investment. Pai asserted that focusing financial resources on long-term outcomes, rather than immediate profits, is crucial for high-tech ventures to flourish. Regulatory restrictions on foreign investment in domestic startups further limit technological progress. According to Pai, these regulations create barriers for startups seeking international capital. He emphasized the need for a more supportive regulatory environment.

Obstacles and Support in the Indian Tech Startup Ecosystem

Pai added that high-tech startups also face difficulties in finding customers. He illustrated this with an example of a novel fast-charging battery technology for electric vehicles. This innovation failed to attract buyers, despite its potential benefits. Pai stressed the importance of market access for these types of ventures. Social media users discussed hurdles faced when starting technology companies. Funding, reduced import duties on foreign components and equipment were among the challenges cited. Others highlighted cumbersome paperwork and licensing procedures. Some entrepreneurs, however, defended Goyal. They characterized his comments as a well-intentioned and necessary analysis of the startup environment. These entrepreneurs saw Goyal’s statements as constructive criticism, aimed at driving positive change within the sector.

Image Credit - BBC

Navigating the Path to Global Tech Leadership

Proxy Gyan educational technology app developer Vironika S expressed support for India’s ambitions to achieve global market dominance through AI and advanced components. While optimistic about India’s potential, Vironika S acknowledged practical obstacles. These obstacles necessitate government intervention to facilitate growth. She called for the government to streamline processes and reduce bureaucratic hurdles. Domestic investor Kushal Bhagia publicly shared his agreement with the Commerce Minister’s assessment of India’s unfulfilled potential in large-scale technological ambitions. Bhagia attributed this lack of ambition to two main factors. One factor was the loss of homegrown talent to American companies. The second factor was the absence of experienced tech entrepreneurs who could mentor aspiring innovators. He argued that mentorship and knowledge transfer are critical for nurturing a thriving tech ecosystem.

Contrasting Indian and Chinese Startup Trajectories

Several news publications analyzed the differing approaches of Indian and Chinese startups following Goyal's statements. Reporter Abhijeet Kumar, writing in Business Standard, noted that a smaller proportion of Indian startup investments went into deep tech fields compared to a larger proportion in China during 2023. Kumar highlighted China’s state-driven push for high-tech development, which included tax breaks for relevant companies in 2024. He pointed out that government support plays a crucial role in shaping the direction of technological advancement.

An opinion piece in the same publication observed that Indian startups primarily focused on local issues, often employing readily available applications rather than global solutions involving deep tech designs. The authors acknowledged that Indian deep tech ventures attracted significant funding in 2024 but maintained that further progress requires more effort. They argued for a shift towards more ambitious, globally focused solutions.

The publication projected a substantial increase in the number of Indian deep tech companies by 2030, with expert commentary suggesting a massive year-on-year increase in funding. Despite this promising trajectory, more needs to be done to enhance India's global competitiveness. The commentary concluded that Goyal’s remarks should serve as a catalyst, prompting investors and the government to allocate capital specifically for deep tech ventures. It also highlighted the importance of fostering growth through academic partnerships and incentives, encouraging advancements in machine learning, advanced machinery, genetic engineering, and clean energy technologies.

Image Credit - BBC

Challenges and Solutions for Indian Startups

India's startup ecosystem, while rapidly growing, faces various obstacles. These challenges include access to funding, navigating regulatory hurdles, intense market competition, talent acquisition, and inadequate infrastructure. Securing funding can be difficult, but developing compelling business plans and exploring alternative sources like crowdfunding and government grants can help mitigate this issue.

Navigating the complex regulatory environment requires startups to stay informed and seek professional advice. To stand out in a competitive market, startups need to differentiate their offerings and focus on innovation. Attracting and retaining talent demands competitive compensation packages and a positive work culture. Forming strategic partnerships with tech companies can provide startups with the necessary tools and resources at reduced costs, enabling them to focus on innovation and growth.

Market access and distribution present further hurdles. Limited reach, lack of established distribution networks, and high logistical costs can impede growth. Competing with established players, who already have extensive distribution channels and brand recognition, makes it difficult for startups to gain market share. Customer acquisition and retention, alongside economic and policy uncertainties, also pose significant challenges.

Government Support for Indian Startups

The Indian government has implemented several schemes to support the startup ecosystem. The Startup India initiative offers tax exemptions, funding support, simplified compliance processes, and a dedicated platform for networking. Stand-Up India facilitates bank loans for startups from marginalized communities.

The Startup India Fund of Funds (FFS) invests in venture capital funds that support startups, while the Credit Guarantee Fund Trust for Micro and Small Enterprises (CGTMSE) provides collateral-free guarantees for loans. The Atal Innovation Mission (AIM) fosters innovation in schools, universities, and businesses. The SAMRIDH scheme supports product-based startups, and the Support for International Patent Protection in Electronics & IT (SIP-EIT) scheme assists with patent filing costs.

The Digital India Bhashini Initiative supports startups developing language technology solutions. The Government e-Marketplace (GeM) provides startups with a platform to sell their products and services to government agencies. MUDRA Banks (Pradhan Mantri MUDRA Yojana – PMMY) offer loans to micro and small enterprises, including startups.

The MeitY Startup Hub (MSH) provides a platform for startups in the IT and electronics sector, while the Startup India Seed Fund Scheme (SISFS) offers financial assistance for early-stage startups. The Aatmanirbhar Bharat App Innovation Challenge promotes the development of indigenous apps.

Focusing on Deep Tech and Global Expansion

The deep tech sector in India is experiencing significant growth, but access to funding remains a major challenge. Securing investment for scaling operations is crucial for these startups, and attracting and retaining talent in a competitive market adds another layer of difficulty. Achieving global expansion requires overcoming regulatory and market entry barriers.

Government initiatives, such as co-investment programs and support for patient capital, are vital for attracting more investors. However, the long development timelines inherent in deep tech often deter investors. A multi-pronged approach is needed to address these challenges.

Government action should focus on strengthening innovation clusters, providing access to patient capital and computing infrastructure, expediting the National Deep Tech Startup Policy, improving intellectual property frameworks, and developing a robust talent pipeline.

Navigating the Complexities of the Indian Startup Ecosystem

Startups in India encounter a range of challenges, from securing funding and navigating regulations to competing in crowded markets and attracting talent. Funding constraints often pose a significant hurdle, especially for early-stage ventures. Exploring diverse funding avenues, including angel investors, venture capital, government schemes, and crowdfunding, can help startups access the necessary capital. Registering as a startup in India can also unlock access to valuable resources and incentives. Regulatory complexities can be time-consuming and costly, but initiatives like Startup India Registration aim to simplify the process, providing support and guidance for startups.

Intense competition in saturated markets requires startups to differentiate themselves. Focusing on unique value propositions, effective marketing strategies, and strong customer engagement can help startups stand out and capture market share. Attracting and retaining skilled individuals is crucial for innovation and execution. Effective talent acquisition strategies, coupled with attractive growth opportunities and a positive work environment, can help startups build strong teams.

Infrastructure gaps, whether physical or digital, can significantly impact business operations. Advocating for improved infrastructure, leveraging technology, and adapting to existing limitations can enhance efficiency and overcome these challenges. Customer acquisition and retention are ongoing priorities in a dynamic market. Focusing on customer needs, crafting personalized experiences, and building strong relationships can drive customer loyalty and sustain growth. Scaling operations while maintaining quality and efficiency can be complex, but strategic planning, process optimization, and a measured approach to expansion can ensure sustainable growth and long-term success.

Image Credit - BBC

Government Initiatives to Support Indian Startups

The Indian government has introduced several schemes to bolster the startup ecosystem. The Startup India initiative offers a range of benefits, including tax exemptions, funding support, simplified compliance processes, and a platform for networking. Stand-Up India facilitates bank loans for startups from marginalized communities, promoting inclusivity and entrepreneurship.

The Startup India Fund of Funds (FFS) invests in venture capital funds that, in turn, support startups, providing a crucial source of indirect funding. The Credit Guarantee Fund Trust for Micro and Small Enterprises (CGTMSE) offers collateral-free guarantees for loans, making it easier for startups to access credit. The Atal Innovation Mission (AIM) fosters innovation in schools, universities, and businesses, nurturing a culture of creativity and problem-solving.

The SAMRIDH scheme supports product-based startups, helping them refine their offerings and reach the market. The Support for International Patent Protection in Electronics & IT (SIP-EIT) scheme assists startups with the costs associated with filing patents, protecting their intellectual property, and encouraging global competitiveness. The Digital India Bhashini Initiative supports startups developing language technology solutions, promoting accessibility and digital inclusion.

The Government e-Marketplace (GeM) provides startups with a platform to sell their products and services to government agencies, opening up new market opportunities. MUDRA Banks (Pradhan Mantri MUDRA Yojana – PMMY) offer loans to micro and small enterprises, including startups, providing much-needed financial support. The MeitY Startup Hub (MSH) provides a platform for IT and electronics startups, while the Startup India Seed Fund Scheme (SISFS) offers crucial early-stage financial assistance.

The Emergence of Deep Tech in India

Deep tech, encompassing cutting-edge technologies like AI, biotechnology, quantum computing, and advanced materials, is rapidly gaining traction in India. These ventures, rooted in scientific and engineering breakthroughs, have the potential to revolutionize industries and solve complex global challenges.

Tech startups face unique obstacles. High R&D costs, regulatory hurdles, and talent shortages are among the key challenges. Securing funding for these capital-intensive ventures requires convincing investors of the long-term potential. Navigating complex regulations and intellectual property frameworks is also essential for success. Attracting and retaining individuals with specialized skill sets in fields like quantum mechanics or genetic engineering is vital for innovation. Despite these difficulties, the potential for disruption and positive impact is immense.

Deep tech ventures often operate on a global scale, targeting large, underpenetrated markets. They generate a higher number of patents compared to traditional tech ventures, highlighting their focus on innovation and intellectual property. The founders typically have strong technical backgrounds, demonstrating the specialized knowledge required in this sector.

The government is increasingly recognizing the importance of deep tech. Initiatives and policies are being developed to support these ventures, acknowledging their potential to drive economic growth and address pressing societal needs. The focus is on fostering collaboration between academia, industry, and government to accelerate the development and commercialization of deep tech solutions.

Building a robust talent pipeline through specialized training programs and attracting global expertise are key priorities. The government is also working towards streamlining regulations and creating a more conducive environment for deep tech startups to thrive.

India's Deep Tech Sector: A Growing Force

India's deep tech sector is rapidly emerging as a key driver of innovation and economic growth. Reports suggest a significant presence of deep tech startups in India, ranging from a few hundred to over 10,000, depending on the classification criteria. The Nasscom-Zinnov report identifies over 500 "inventive" deep tech startups, while the draft National Deep Tech Startup Policy (NDTSP) 2023 lists over 10,000 DPIIT-recognized deep tech startups as of May 2023. These startups operate across diverse sectors, including healthcare, mobility, infrastructure, space, AI, and robotics.

"Inventive" deep tech startups, focusing on creating new technologies rather than simply applying existing ones, are expected to be the primary drivers of change. These startups are experiencing rapid growth, attracting significant investment, and contributing to India's ambition of becoming a global deep tech leader. Estimates from October 2024 indicate over 3,600 deep tech startups in India, with over 480 established in 2023 alone.

These figures highlight the dynamism and rapid expansion of the sector. The government recognizes the potential of deep tech and has implemented various initiatives to support its growth. These initiatives include the Startup India Seed Fund Scheme, the National Mission on Quantum Technologies and Applications, and the NDTSP 2023. The Anusandhan National Research Foundation further strengthens the research and development ecosystem, fostering innovation in deep tech. The Indian government's commitment to fostering a thriving deep tech ecosystem is evident through these initiatives, which aim to create a conducive environment for innovation, research, and development in this crucial sector.

Investment Trends and Opportunities in Deep Tech

Investment in deep tech has seen significant fluctuations over the years. While funding peaked in 2022 at $2.77 billion, it experienced a decline in 2023 and 2024. However, early-stage funding has shown resilience, indicating continued investor confidence in the long-term potential of deep tech.

Despite these fluctuations, early-stage venture capital firms remain committed to ramping up investments in deep tech, underscoring the belief in the transformative power of these technologies. Larger VC firms are also increasingly participating in the deep tech space, recognizing the sector's potential for disruptive innovation.

India's deep tech industry is estimated to account for over 20% of venture capital investments, demonstrating its growing importance within the investment landscape. Venture capitalists are increasingly focusing on early-stage deep tech startups, even underwriting significant technology risks. This shift reflects a maturing ecosystem that recognizes the long-term value of these ventures.

Sectors like semiconductors and biotech have seen growth in early-stage funding, enabling startups to scale and develop indigenous capabilities. India's strategic position and supportive policies attract international collaborations, further strengthening the deep tech ecosystem. Startups like Agnikul Cosmos, with its successful launch of the world's first 3D-printed rocket engine, and Mindgrove Technologies, developing 28nm chips, exemplify India's deep tech potential.

These achievements underscore India's growing capabilities in advanced technologies and its ambition to become a global leader.

Government Support and Policy Initiatives

Government support plays a critical role in nurturing the growth of deep tech. The Indian government has launched several initiatives to create a favorable environment for deep tech startups.

The Startup India initiative provides tax benefits, simplified regulations, and access to funding. The National Deep Tech Startup Policy further strengthens the ecosystem by promoting research, development, and commercialization. Increased funding for research institutions and the establishment of Centres of Excellence in AI demonstrate the government's commitment to advancing deep tech.

The Production-Linked Incentive (PLI) scheme for drones encourages domestic manufacturing and export, positioning India as a key player in the global drone market. The government's allocation of ₹20,000 crore to drive private sector research and development further underscores its commitment to deep tech.

A dedicated deep tech fund is also under consideration, indicating a long-term vision for the sector's growth. The government's active role in fostering collaboration between academia, industry, and government accelerates the development and commercialization of deep tech solutions. These combined efforts aim to transform India into a global deep tech leader.

The Future of Deep Tech in India

The convergence of government support, increased investor confidence, and a growing pool of entrepreneurial talent positions India for continued growth in the deep tech sector. Experts predict a surge in Series A funding and beyond, indicating the maturation of the ecosystem.

Greater collaboration between academia, government, and industry is expected to drive innovation further. Increased participation from generalist funds will support deep tech innovations at the early stage. A stronger focus on commercialization will translate research into marketable products.

More experienced professionals from larger companies are anticipated to join the startup ecosystem, bringing valuable expertise. These factors point to a bright future for deep tech in India. The sector is well-positioned to attract international investments and partnerships, driving innovation and economic growth.

With a focus on addressing local challenges and tapping into global markets, Indian deep tech startups are set to create a significant impact in the years to come.

The Deep Tech Revolution: Reshaping India's Future

India's burgeoning deep tech sector is poised to revolutionize its economy and position the nation as a global innovation hub. Deep tech, encompassing groundbreaking advancements in artificial intelligence, biotechnology, advanced materials, and electronics, is not merely an incremental improvement on existing technologies. It represents a paradigm shift, driven by fundamental scientific breakthroughs with the potential to reshape industries and address critical global challenges.

This transformative potential is attracting significant attention from investors, policymakers, and entrepreneurs alike. Reports suggest that India is home to thousands of deep tech startups. These startups operate across diverse sectors, ranging from healthcare and agriculture to space technology and clean energy.

India's deep tech sector is characterized by its focus on solving complex problems. This problem-solving approach is fueled by strong research and development capabilities, a growing talent pool, and increasing government support. The sector's emphasis on intellectual property and innovation distinguishes it from traditional IT services. This focus positions India as a creator of cutting-edge technologies rather than just a consumer or implementer.

The confluence of these factors creates a fertile ground for the growth and maturation of deep tech in India. The sector is expected to play a crucial role in driving economic growth, creating high-skilled jobs, and enhancing India's global competitiveness.

Key Drivers of Deep Tech Growth in India

Several factors contribute to the rapid growth of deep tech in India. Government initiatives, such as the Startup India program, the National Deep Tech Startup Policy, and substantial funding allocations for research and development, provide crucial support for the sector.

These policies aim to create a conducive environment for innovation by simplifying regulations, offering tax incentives, and fostering collaboration between academia and industry. India's vast pool of skilled engineers and scientists provides a strong talent base for deep tech ventures. The increasing availability of specialized training programs and research facilities further strengthens this talent pipeline.

Growing investor interest, both domestic and international, is providing deep tech startups with the capital needed to scale their operations. The rise of venture capital firms specializing in deep tech and the increasing participation of generalist funds demonstrate growing confidence in the sector's potential.

India's large and diverse domestic market offers deep tech startups a valuable testing ground for their innovations. This access to a large market allows them to refine their products and scale their operations before expanding globally.

The convergence of government support, a skilled workforce, investor confidence, and a large domestic market positions India as an attractive destination for deep tech innovation.

Addressing Challenges and Realizing the Potential

Despite its promising trajectory, India's deep tech sector faces certain challenges. Securing funding, particularly for later-stage ventures, remains a hurdle. The long gestation periods and high capital requirements of deep tech projects can deter some investors.

Attracting and retaining top talent in a competitive global market requires offering competitive compensation and creating a stimulating work environment. Navigating complex regulatory landscapes and intellectual property frameworks can be time-consuming and resource-intensive.

Addressing these challenges requires a multi-pronged approach. Strengthening the funding ecosystem through initiatives like dedicated deep tech funds and encouraging patient capital can provide startups with the long-term support they need.

Promoting collaboration between academia, industry, and government can accelerate research and development, facilitate technology transfer, and foster a culture of innovation. Streamlining regulations and simplifying intellectual property procedures can reduce bureaucratic hurdles and encourage entrepreneurship.

By addressing these challenges effectively, India can unlock the full potential of its deep tech sector and achieve its ambition of becoming a global leader in innovation.

The Path to Global Leadership: A Collaborative Approach

India's aspiration to become a global deep tech leader requires a collaborative and strategic approach. Fostering strong partnerships between academia, industry, and government is crucial for translating research into marketable products and services.

Encouraging international collaborations can provide access to global markets, expertise, and resources. Investing in research and development, particularly in emerging areas like quantum computing and synthetic biology, can position India at the forefront of technological advancements.

Developing a robust intellectual property framework can protect innovations and encourage further research and development. Creating a supportive regulatory environment that fosters innovation, encourages risk-taking, and simplifies compliance procedures can attract investment and talent.

Building a strong talent pipeline through specialized training programs, attracting global experts, and fostering a culture of entrepreneurship is essential for long-term success. By embracing these strategies, India can establish itself as a global deep tech powerhouse.

This will drive economic growth, address critical challenges, and shape a future driven by innovation.