Trading Standards Vs Crime Gangs

High Street Under Siege: The Endless War on Britain's Illicit Tobacco Gangs

Along a single mile of a street close to Newport's heart, a stark picture of a nationwide problem emerges. Over the preceding nine months, authorities have shut down nineteen separate shops because they were trading in illicit tobacco and vapes. This cluster of closures represents just one front in a relentless battle against a shadow economy. This trade thrives on street corners and in unassuming mini-marts across the country. This represents a daily, visible challenge to the law.

The distribution of these prohibited items is a shameful crime that cultivates deep-seated problems within the community. The closures are victories, but they are often temporary. The fight is not just about counterfeit products; it is for the safety and stability of the neighbourhoods these shops inhabit. The situation is viewed with gravity as the illicit trade creates significant issues for residents and legitimate businesses alike.

A Battle for Britain's Main Commercial Roads

What is happening in South Wales offers a look into a shadowy realm. Criminal gangs exploit forced labour. They staff small convenience stores with undocumented employees. They use cars to ferry narcotics and fraudulent cigarettes across towns. Enforcement officials describe it as a perpetual fight against this pervasive trade. This fight is not confined to one town or region; it is an issue for Britain.

Residents and legitimate business owners live with the consequences. Fear is a constant companion, with accounts of threats becoming commonplace. Unconcealed narcotics sales occur on streets where children walk. An assault with acid, a terrifying escalation of violence, was linked to a dispute involving mini-market employees. This criminal activity casts a long shadow over daily life.

On the Frontline with Trading Standards

Officials from Trading Standards are at the forefront of this fight. They face sophisticated and determined criminal networks. In Newport, the local team is in charge of the recent shop closures. Their work is a constant cycle of investigation, raids, and legal action. The objective is to disrupt the trade and restore some semblance of order to the affected communities.

However, the challenge is immense. The officers confront a hydra-headed opponent. For every shop they manage to close, another seems to spring up. The criminals are adaptable, often reopening shuttered premises under new guises or simply shifting to an empty property nearby. The officers' dedication is unwavering, but they are acutely aware of the scale of the task ahead.

A Legitimate Trader's Frustration

Erol Kaya, an individual of Kurdish heritage from Turkey, has made South Wales his home for twenty-six years. He runs a lawful global food market on that very Newport road where nineteen illicit shops were closed. He observes the audacious peddling of prohibited items daily with growing frustration and anger. His voice rises with emotion as he describes his struggle.

Kaya diligently pays his taxes, and his staff do the same. Yet, he sees others generating illicit funds with impunity. His customers have confessed their fear of visiting the street, particularly after dusk. The criminality is not just unfair competition; it is actively driving away the customers that legitimate businesses like his depend on to survive.

The National Scale: A Pervasive Enterprise

The problem extends far beyond Newport. Data via Freedom of Information requests show that officials confiscated unlawful vapes and tobacco from 3,624 stores throughout England, Wales, and Scotland in 2024-25. These figures, compiled from 169 separate municipal Trading Standards departments, offer a substantial, if incomplete, snapshot of the issue.

The seizures predominantly occurred at convenience retailers and vape outlets. However, the illicit goods were also discovered in an unexpected range of other main street businesses. Food outlets, establishments for beauty treatments, and one shop that mends carpets were implicated. This demonstrates the deep infiltration of this illegal trade into the fabric of local commerce, making it harder to contain.

The Financial Toll: Bleeding the Public Purse

The illicit trade carries a significant economic cost. It jeopardises lawful businesses, bankrolls broader criminal operations, and damages public well-being. The financial impact is stark. In the 2022-23 tax year, the duty gap for tobacco was estimated at £2.2 billion. This figure represents lost revenue that would otherwise fund essential public services.

The tobacco duty gap for 2023-24 was 13.8%. While this is a reduction from previous years, the problem persists, particularly with hand-rolling tobacco. Every packet sold covertly is a loss to the Treasury and a gain for organised crime. This continuous drain on public finances weakens the state's ability to respond to the very problems the trade creates.

Organised Crime's New Cash Cow

This is not simply opportunistic street-level crime. This is a highly organised, lucrative enterprise. Authorities within South Wales have uncovered a complex web of criminality. Gangs use forced labour and illegal workers to run their retail fronts. These operations are intricately linked to broader criminal networks involved in drug distribution and human trafficking.

The profits from illicit tobacco are substantial, sometimes rivalling those from narcotics. This makes the trade an attractive venture for established criminal groups. The fight against fake cigarettes is therefore a fight against organised crime. The mini-marts on the main commercial road are often just the visible tip of a much larger and more dangerous iceberg.

Operation CeCe: A Coordinated Strike

In response to this growing threat, authorities have launched initiatives like Operation CeCe. This is a national programme that involves a partnership to combat the unlawful tobacco trade head-on. The operation focuses on disrupting the supply chain, from importation to street-level sales. It promotes collaboration between different agencies to maximise their impact.

Since its launch in 2021, Operation CeCe has achieved significant results. By November 2024, the initiative had successfully removed 27 million unlawful cigarettes and 7,500kg of hand-rolling tobacco from the market. These seizures represent a major blow to the criminal gangs and demonstrate the benefit of a coordinated, intelligence-led approach to enforcement.

Image Credit - Freepik

The Swansea Connection: A Counterfeit Hub

Swansea has emerged as a key central point for fake hand-rolling tobacco. The trade in the city is largely managed by Chinese criminal groups generating incredible sums of money. These groups exploit vulnerable nationals from China, admitted on student permits, who are compelled into unlawful employment in the illicit operation.

These workers are tasked with stuffing thousands of packets of tobacco each week. The counterfeit product is then funnelled to gangs that are mainly Kurdish. These groups handle the final stage of distribution, selling the tobacco covertly in small markets across the region. This two-tiered system highlights the sophisticated and international nature of the criminal enterprise.

Exploitation and Fear

The toll on people from this industry is huge. During a raid in Swansea, authorities for immigration detained an Iraqi Kurd. He was an individual seeking asylum who lacked permission to be employed in the UK and was suspected of managing a vehicle used for hiding tobacco. This case illustrates the clear link between the illicit trade and immigration crime.

The gangs prey on vulnerable individuals, exploiting their circumstances for profit. Shop workers, too, live in a state of fear. Three retail employees in the South Wales area described the constant threat of violence. One witnessed an assault with acid amidst a conflict involving employees of a mini-market, a chilling example of the brutality that underpins this trade.

London's Challenge: A Game of Whack-a-Mole

In east London, the fight is just as challenging. Within the local authority of Barking and Dagenham, a Trading Standards inspection of a sparsely stocked convenience store was the fourth such visit. The proprietors of the enterprise are elusive, a common tactic that makes it incredibly difficult to permanently close such shops.

On every previous visit, officers have found concealments. This time, a detection dog found caches of prohibited tobacco and cigarettes concealed within a specially built partition, with an estimated value of over £5,000. While this is sufficient to justify a temporary closure, the law requires proof that the premises are linked to antisocial behaviour, a significant legal hurdle.

Concealed and Elusive: Inside an Illicit Operation

Criminals use sophisticated methods to hide their illicit stock. Officers across the country report finding purpose-built concealments, often operated by complex mechanisms. In one Walsall store, a wall hide was secured with an electromagnet system. Other finds include illegal goods hidden behind shop counters, in storerooms, and even in toilet areas.

This ingenuity extends to ownership. The people running the shops are often not the true owners, making prosecution difficult. They are merely the public face of a much larger, shadowy organisation. This structure is designed to protect the senior figures in the criminal hierarchy, leaving enforcement officials to deal with a revolving door of low-level operatives.

The Enforcement Gap: Why Shops Reopen

Despite the efforts of Trading Standards, many shops simply reappear after being closed. Municipal councils possess restricted capabilities to address the issue efficiently. Even when a closure order is granted, it is usually only for a three-month period. Under 300 stores were closed using this measure in the last twelve months.

This creates a frustrating cycle for officers and residents. A shop is closed, the illegal activity pauses, and then it resumes as soon as the order expires. Back in Newport, while some shuttered businesses remain closed, others have clearly resumed operations. Outside, young men can be seen talking and smoking, a clear sign that the problem has not gone away.

Stash Cars: Mobile Warehouses of Crime

To minimise losses during raids, gangs often store the bulk of their illegal stock off-site. Vehicles used to hide goods situated close to the shops serve as mobile warehouses. When stock runs low in the store, a runner simply fetches more from a nearby vehicle. This tactic makes it harder for officers to seize the full extent of the criminal enterprise's assets.

In Swansea, these vehicles might hold more than just counterfeit cigarettes. The operation involves a dual trade: tobacco during the day and drugs at night. This highlights the dangerous convergence of different forms of organised crime, with the unlawful tobacco industry acting as a gateway for other illegal activities.

A Community Gripped by Fear

The presence of this criminality has a corrosive effect on communities. One woman in the South Wales region, with more than three decades of experience in a local store, observes narcotics transactions each morning. She lamented the lack of control, stating that the area no longer feels like her home, her words capturing a sense of loss and insecurity.

Another resident, Daniel, holding both UK and Chinese citizenship, is deeply troubled by the constant law enforcement actions and illegal behaviour on his main road. He said this reality makes him feel insecure, noting that he has children. Residing in Swansea for a large portion of his life, he is now seriously considering relocating his family to reside in Hong Kong to escape the deteriorating situation.

The Next Generation: A Looming Youth Vaping Crisis

Alongside illicit tobacco, the trade in illegal vapes is surging. This presents a new and alarming challenge, particularly concerning the health of young people. Data shows that 7.6 per cent of 11 to 17-year-olds now vape regularly or occasionally. The colourful packaging and fruity flavours of many illegal vapes make them attractive to children.

In the final quarter of 2023-24, nearly a quarter of test purchases conducted by Trading Standards resulted in illegal retailing of vapes to children under 18. This demonstrates a widespread failure of compliance among some retailers and a direct threat to the wellbeing of the next generation. Nicotine is highly addictive, and the long-term health effects of vaping are still not fully understood.

Illegal Vapes: A Toxic Trade

The scale of the illegal vape trade is staggering. In the 2023-24 period, Trading Standards seized over 1.19 million illegal vapes, a 59% increase on the previous year. These products are not just illegal; they are often dangerous. Most fail to meet basic UK safety standards, containing banned ingredients or excessive levels of nicotine.

A legal disposable vape in the UK should have a capacity of no more than 2ml and a puff count of around 600. However, seized products often contain up to 10,000 or even 15,000 puffs, delivering a massive, unregulated dose of nicotine. Operation Joseph, a national initiative, is now dedicated to tracking and tackling the retailing of these harmful products.

The Legal Maze: Why Enforcers Feel Powerless

Officials from Trading Standards frequently feel constrained by current laws. A necessity exists for more straightforward legislation and additional funding to aid their efforts. Under the current framework, local government bodies can seek closure directives from magistrates' courts, but the bar for success is high.

A court can grant these directives only when it is demonstrated that a business constitutes a severe annoyance to the public or that disruptive, offensive, or illegal activities are probable. This can be difficult to demonstrate in court. As a result, many councils struggle to use these powers effectively, leaving criminal enterprises to operate with relative impunity.

A Question of Powers: The Call for Stronger Legislation

There is a growing consensus that tougher rules are needed. While convictions can now lead to penalties as high as £10,000, this sum can be dwarfed by the profits from selling counterfeit goods. More permanent closures are rare and usually only happen when Trading Standards can work with landlords to evict the tenants who are accountable for the illegal activity.

Advocates press the government to enact laws that fortify licensing requirements for tobacco retailing. There is a call for a system that would make it easier to strip retailers of their right to sell tobacco if they are caught dealing in illicit products. This would provide a stronger deterrent against this type of criminal activity.

Image Credit - Freepik

The Government's Pledge: Patrols and Port Security

The government has acknowledged the problem. It has stated that more than 500 urban centres are receiving additional local patrols, which will be significant in suppressing the trade in illicit tobacco merchandise. The effectiveness of these patrols in deterring organised crime remains to be seen.

Border Force is also striving to prevent these items from reaching retail shelves initially. The scale of seizures at the border is significant, with the agency confiscating more than 97 tonnes of unlawful tobacco in the previous year. This is a critical part of the fight, aimed at cutting off the supply at its source.

The Disposable Vape Ban

In a significant policy shift, the UK government has banned the sale and supply of single-use disposable vapes, with the law taking effect from 1 June 2025. This move is driven by dual concerns: the alarming rise in youth vaping and the severe environmental impact of the devices. The ban makes it illegal for any retailer to sell the products, with offenders facing fines and potential jail time.

This legislation forces the market to evolve towards reusable and refillable alternatives. However, there are early signs of challenges. Retailers report difficulties in stocking the necessary refill pods, which could lead to consumers treating the new reusable devices as single-use, undermining the ban's intent.

Undermining Public Health

The prohibited tobacco industry poses a significant threat to public health. The availability of cheap, unregulated cigarettes and tobacco undermines decades of progress in reducing smoking rates. High taxes on legal tobacco are a key tool for encouraging smokers to quit, but this strategy is rendered less effective when criminals offer a low-cost alternative.

While the prohibited market has shrunk over an extended period, it continues to be a point of worry. Counterfeit products carry additional health risks, as they are produced without any quality control. They can contain higher levels of tar, nicotine, and other harmful substances, and some may not self-extinguish, creating a fire hazard.

A Call for a Smokefree Future

Health advocates argue that the ultimate solution is to create a "smokefree generation." There are calls for the administration to not only strengthen licensing rules but to also move towards phasing out the retailing of tobacco altogether. This ambitious goal would eliminate the illicit market by removing the demand for tobacco products entirely.

This vision is complemented by measures in the proposed bill for Tobacco and Vaping products, which aims to stop anyone born after January 1, 2009, from ever legally buying tobacco. By making it harder for young people to start smoking, the government hopes to create a future where the battle against illicit tobacco is no longer necessary.

Conclusion: The Future of Main Street

The situation on the streets of Newport, Swansea, and London is a stark reminder of the battle being waged for the time ahead for Britain's main commercial roads. This is a conflict that pits under-resourced local authorities against adaptable and ruthless criminal networks. The fight is not just about seizing contraband; it is about protecting communities, safeguarding public health, and ensuring that legitimate businesses can thrive.

For people like Erol Kaya, the concerned shopkeeper in Newport, the stakes are deeply personal. The feeling that the nation lacks strength to protect its citizens and their future is a powerful motivator for change. His concerns echo the fears of many who see this shadow economy not just as a nuisance, but as a fundamental threat to the society they call home.